The Jewish Psychedelic Podcast

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Dr. Rachel Yehuda

Dr. Rachel Yehuda, one of the world’s foremost experts on epigenetic trauma and psychedelic-assisted therapies, joins Rabbi Zac for a conversation about the significance of the Jewish story as a foundation for processing ancestral traumas. They speak about Rachel’s upbringing, the history of trauma research, and the future of MDMA-assisted therapy.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

  • Rachel Yehuda, PhD, is an Endowed Professor of Psychiatry and Neuroscience of Trauma.  She is also Director of Mental Health at the James J. Peters Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Dr. Yehuda is a recognized leader in the field of traumatic stress studies, PTSD, and intergenerational trauma.  In 2019, Dr. Yehuda was elected to the National Academy of Medicine for her seminal contributions to understanding the psychological and biological impact of traumatic stress.  In 2020, Dr. Yehuda established and now directs the Center for Psychedelic Psychotherapy and Trauma Research.

  • 00:01.34

    shefaflow

    Today I'm joined by Dr Rachel Yehuda who is an endowed professor of psychiatry and neuroscience of trauma. She's also the director of mental health at the James J Peters Veterans Affairs Medical Center and she's a recognized leader in the field of traumatic stress studies. Post-traumatic stress disorder and intergenerational trauma and 2019 Dr Yehuda was elected to the national Academy Of Medicine for her seminal contributions to understanding the psychological and biological impact of traumatic stress and in 20 Dr. Yehuda established and now directs the center for psychedelic therapy research cptr at the Icann school of medicine at Mount Sinai Dr. Yehuda thank you for being on the jewish psychedelic podcast.

    00:49.97

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well thank you for asking me to be on the podcast.

    00:52.80

    shefaflow

    Absolutely well, we've had an interesting history I remember the the first time that I called you somebody gave me your phone number and I remember it felt a little like who is this person why is he asking me these questions and what does this have to do with judaism. So.

    01:10.93

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, but I didn't answer them but I did answer them.

    01:11.46

    shefaflow

    I think we've come a long way. What's that you did answer them. Thank you? Um, well as is as is my habit when I get to talk to you I like to ask you about your father a blessed memory your father. For people who don't know was ratzvi huda who was a student of the haszanish and he himself was one of the greatest teachers of ghazal and Halaja he knew topics upon topics beyond just those 2 and one of the greatest teachers of his generation. What was it like for you and your siblings to grow up in your household with this this kind of person.

    01:57.20

    Rachel Yehuda

    Yeah, was like living in the fourth century in many ways because what was on my father's mind a lot um was what he was learning and what he was studying and he always pulled us into it.If he was learning about something that had to do with shabbat or the jewish holidays or an ethical issue. We would know about it and we would be asked what we thought about it. Um, and when we would come home from school I was always asked. What did I learn today. What did you learn today and when I would just simply tell him something that I thought wouldn't make him go away of he would say well now I know what your teacher said but I asked you what you learned so he was very. Much interested in developing our minds making us learn to interact with jewish thoughts and ideas really trying to highlight that there isn't one way that it's a dialogue. It's a dialectic It's a place where different people really do use different approaches to um, try to arrive at the truth. He was very big on the truth wanting to know really what things mean and. Very big on intellectual honesty. So I think that those were really important values in my home.

    03:35.42

    shefaflow

    So The life of the mind but it also feels like he had some degree of emotional attunement to his his daughter. Um did he impart. More than just his intellectual acumen in that way to you his feeling for these things.

    03:54.16

    Rachel Yehuda

    Yeah, so it was one and the same it wasn't just a subject that was studied. It was it had implications for the way you were going to lead your life. Um, that the kind of things that the rabbis talked about were important that they molded your character.

    04:10.23

    Rachel Yehuda

    Whether something would be a humanistic view for example or really more of a sheltered view. Those things were important did the rabbis care about all people. Um, and so every chance he got he would show the moral lesson. Show that there is something to be learned about being kind being humanistic compassionate thinking about the other person. Ah and those were were important. Those were important things for him.

    04:48.92

    shefaflow

    Um, did he? um as ah as a ah scholar of Jewish Texts and linguistics and philosophy did. He also have what to share with you about theology in any way or was that. Ah, different kind of conversation where did those where did those topics come in in your life.

    05:11.83

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well I don't think I don't remember evers having a conversation about theology per se which is interesting I mean I remember having a lot of conversations about the odyssey of whether you can feel that um, but not but I don't.

    05:24.81

    shefaflow

    Ah.

    05:29.34

    Rachel Yehuda

    Think so in that you know the classic is there a God kind of thing I don't I think I think that was either that was either given or irrelevant make it.

    05:44.18

    shefaflow

    M four.

    05:47.64

    Rachel Yehuda

    So um, yeah, no I don't I don't think we talked about things like that I mean we would talk about things he wrote a book about job. For example, eove and so we talked about you know how do you interact with people who are suffering. Um, how do you not judge them because only God can really do that? Um, what you know? what are the stages of suffering and um, you know is there suffering without reason and what what is the book really about as a.

    06:24.43

    Rachel Yehuda

    As a biblical contribution. So um, he really liked his 1 of his favorites was shir how she read the song of songs which he absolutely believed was about the love between a man and a woman. Um, and. Ah, yeah, things like that. But he lived it. He breathed it. It was very palpable.

    06:49.76

    shefaflow

    Maybe we can come back to what it was like as the daughter of such a scholar focused on human suffering and then finding your way into um, a field where you're. Focused on the alleviation of suffering. But maybe you could also speak about your mother Hasia I've actually never heard very much about her. But if you could just bring her into the conversation too.

    07:16.14

    Rachel Yehuda

    Yeshasia is alive and well ah, living in Jerusalem and she was really quite devoted to um, ah to us and to my father and to the family.

    07:31.93

    Rachel Yehuda

    Casia's talent is musical and she was a choir conductor for many years and I don't think there's a Jewish piece of music that she wouldn't be able to identify. Fact we've called her many times when people wanted to identify a certain piece of music and she'll they'll say oh it was written then in this camp it was sung by this person and she'll think for a moment and she'll know she'll come up with it. So She very talented in that. Um.

    07:56.18

    shefaflow

    And.

    08:06.19

    Rachel Yehuda

    And ah as a Sixth -generation israeli she had many many many stories her own upbringing and her own family lineage is a story onto itself because her family was really among the founders of of Jerusalem and Israel.

    08:18.92

    shefaflow

    Um.

    08:25.57

    Rachel Yehuda

    Living in goul at at for many generations. So yeah, very interesting set of parents. Um very Jewish home for very very Jewish. Um, yeah, there wasn't much outside of it. So.

    08:35.70

    shefaflow

    Yeah, the to say the least is.

    08:44.60

    Rachel Yehuda

    Yeah.

    09:09.97

    shefaflow

    Okay, that's okay, thank you so picking up at Nine fifteen um so how did you were born in Israel where were you born in Jerusalem in but yam.

    09:18.81

    Rachel Yehuda

    Yes, no in Batya it actually in yafo was that was where the hospital was technically but my parents were living in batchan at the time I was.

    09:30.99

    shefaflow

    And you grew up there for how many years

    09:36.39

    Rachel Yehuda

    Only a year old when my parents came to the us and my father pursued his master's and his ph d at yeshiba university and then um, my family moved to Cleveland Ohio where my father became a.

    09:51.70

    shefaflow

    Um.

    09:54.86

    Rachel Yehuda

    Ah, Jewish Studies professor.

    09:58.43

    shefaflow

    And so you did a good amount of growing up then in Cleveland um, what was it like for you. What were your surroundings at the time and what were you drawn to as a young person.

    10:12.63

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well, it's kind of suburban living. Um for all its benefits and limitations I guess um at the time. Um I didn't realize how idyllic a life. It was in many ways. Um. Looking back I see that it really was um but we all talked about how when we grew up, we would all move to New York and many of us did at the time I grew up there. The community was small getting bigger.

    10:38.13

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    10:48.16

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, now. It's a very big robust community when I went when I was growing up. There was only 1 jewish school now there are several um there were handful of synagogues now they're really really a lot. Um, but you know it's kind of midwest values. Everyone is kind. Um, and yeah I I'm I love that I'm from Cleveland and when I meet people that are from Cleveland there is a natural connection.

    11:20.90

    shefaflow

    I'm struck a little bit ah by you whenever I speak to you and had the very deep pleasure of spending shabbat with you at the psychedelic science in in Denver that you it feels like you are. Ah, child of the sixty s in some ways and so'm wondering did you have any contact with the counterculture I mean you were you know, almost bat mitzvah around the ah in the 70 s and um, yeah, what? what was your exposure to that or was it you were still insulated from. From those waves those cultural waves.

    11:57.16

    Rachel Yehuda

    I knew about what was happening in the culture. Um, those things probably provoked a mixture of fascination and intimidation. Um, for me I'm more a child of the seventy s I would say I mean I was. Born in 1959 so you know I was pretty young during the sixty s on whatever seep through seep through. Um, yeah.

    12:18.13

    shefaflow

    Um.

    12:28.90

    shefaflow

    Well, um, from your earliest experiences abroad and then in the midwest you received your training as a neurochemist a psychologist and a biological psychiatrist. At both at you m mherst and Yale what drew you to these fields initially and what were you most driven to understand about the human condition through your work.

    12:53.89

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well, yeah I mean there there was a part of me that wanted to be a psychologist and just really understand what what was making people tick and trying to help if I could but I think there was an even. Larger part of me that was a scientist. Um and in the late seventy s when I was trying to figure out what I would study in college they didn't have what they have now which is. Translational neuroscience which is this idea of bringing together psychology and Neuroscience I fairly had neuroscience to be honest, um, it was a very young and emerging field and so what I knew was that I was interested in in really the.

    13:34.24

    shefaflow

    I.

    13:45.99

    Rachel Yehuda

    Intersection of those things. Um, it didn't feel like I could do both then um I did not I am not a medical doctor I did not go to medical school that felt at the time that that would be a. Different thing than being a scientist. Um, of course that's completely not true. Um, for all of you who want to be a scientist going to medical school is a very good way to be a scientist but at the time I I really couldn't quite wrap my head around how I could. Study what I was interested in which was really the the biologic basis of behavior and emotions and why we are the way we are and and things like that. It was so new I mean receptors weren't even really discovered. Dopamine and until the 70 s things like that we we knew so very little but it was exciting and so for graduate school I wanted to do a dual program of neuroscience and psychology. Um. But I ended up focusing more on the neuroscience. Um, it was very hard in graduate school to try to do more than 1 thing. But afterwards I was more interested in going back and seeing if rather than doing animal studies on stress I could apply this to people.

    15:21.38

    Rachel Yehuda

    And so I ended up at yale medical school and doing a postdoctoral fellowship in I guess didn't call it in anything but I guess it was um what I had wanted all along. It was. Found myself in a lab that had just done the first study the first biologic study of post-traumatic stress disorder was a very new disorder back then and that is where I landed and that's what I've been pretty much doing ever since.

    15:48.95

    shefaflow

    Um.

    15:54.97

    shefaflow

    Yeah, well, you're probably most well known at least on the internet for your work with Ptsd and that's why I wanted to ask you it. It feels like in popular culture and discourse and just the ah. Ah, the collective capital of how we speak with each other at least where where I'm living in Berkeley California um it feels like everything is being described as ptsd so I'd love to hear from you the master sit at your feet for a moment. Um, what. Is PSdPtsd and what is not ptsd and why do you think it's being used as frequently frequently as it is right now.

    16:43.33

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well, that's a good question I mean in in one sense. Ptsd is a victim of its own success right? It's it's a term that is being used Beyond its strict definition. Um, as as a shorthand if you will for.

    16:51.25

    shefaflow

    Um, as it be.

    16:59.27

    Rachel Yehuda

    Something bad happened to me and I'm really really affected by it and I'm a good way so that's how most people use it. Um the definition itself really went through many iterations when ptsd first appeared in 1980 in the dsm 3 the intention of the diagnosis was to capture what the experience that many people have or that all people have following um, being exposed to a really markedly distressing unusual horrific event.

    17:37.20

    Rachel Yehuda

    And the idea there was that our current concepts of stress weren't cutting it because the current concept of current concepts of stress suggested that most people recover that people will recover with time that eventually the body will come back to itself. And you know you'll have an ah acute phase where you're very very distressed. But with time you ought to heal. That's the idea behind fight or flight that you kind of recalibrate your hormones and then you got to get back to where you are.

    18:08.35

    shefaflow

    Um.

    18:13.80

    Rachel Yehuda

    But increasingly for many people who were exposed to extreme trauma that wasn't happening. They were still very symptomatic though months and years had passed and so the people who came up with a diagnosis were really trying to find a category for them for. At first they thought it was a function of what happened to you if it was extreme enough. You two would not be able to recover that was the first iteration. But then as research began to happen. People realize that that's not necessarily the case. There's a lot of individual variation in who develops long-term symptoms and who recovers and who doesn't recover and then over the years there have also been different discussions about what symptoms should be in and what symptoms should be out. And so I can't I can give you today's precise definition but I'm not going to do that because it could be different tomorrow but the hallmark of it is really that the memories of a horrible experience. Linger. And that when you have those memories. First of all, you have them even when you don't want to you'rely easily triggered by the environment and um, they bring back with it. A kind of physiologic expression of fight or flight so it makes it very very hard to kind of put put it in the past.

    19:42.44

    Rachel Yehuda

    Because you experience many aspects of the threat in real time and it is actually a common condition because trauma is so common and pervasive in our society.

    19:57.17

    shefaflow

    Um, did you see you mentioned earlier the difference between doing animal and human studies is there. It is is the human experience of stress unique amongst mammals or do other and do other mammals have.

    20:16.37

    shefaflow

    Similar experiences when they encounter traumatic or stressful experiences.

    20:20.69

    Rachel Yehuda

    I would think of it as a Venn diagram really I think that there are a lot of things that are overlapping particularly the fight or flight response particularly some of the hormonal changes in the activation of certain brain regions and the extent. But. With people a lot of how you process trauma has to do with what you think about it how you look back on it. How you integrate it how you process it and it's not clear that animals do that? Um I would have no real way of understanding that. But it's a very.

    20:55.88

    shefaflow

    Of course.

    20:59.18

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, big component of what needs to happen with people who are traumatized and developed Ttsd. So We can learn a lot from animals but I don't think we can learn everything and so the trick of all of this is knowing the point at which. Translation stops and that you have to really start extrapolating about people by studying people but the problem with that is is that we don't have the ability to manipulate people. Um, scientifically the way we can. In animal Studies. So we're going to be limited in what we can learn and in what you know? biologic specimens We can access.

    21:37.50

    shefaflow

    Course.

    21:48.28

    shefaflow

    And is this a particular this diagnosis and this designation is this something that shows up across cultures. It's human experience are there other cultures who um.

    22:04.74

    shefaflow

    Who are able to help process these kinds of experiences more efficiently over others is that is that something that you have looked at or understood or.

    22:18.37

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, it is something that I'm extremely interested in but I'm not an expert. Um I do think that different cultures are able to kind of help people who are traumatized differently depending on how much they come together.

    22:29.50

    shefaflow

    This.

    22:35.14

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, to really be with a trauma survivor after the trauma has happened I mean even in modern studies. Social support has been listed as one of the key factors that prevent ptsd or um. Promote recovery from Ptsd and social support means that really, you're not going through it alone and I think that in cultures where you have a support network and a support system and also an expectation that. Trauma is going to happen adversity does happen and it's not just a matter of if it's a matter of when and then there's kind of an app for that. There's something that you do you come to the person's house you bring food you say prayers. Whatever it is. There's some ritual about it. Um.

    23:22.28

    shefaflow

    Me.

    23:31.33

    Rachel Yehuda

    I Think that those are more healing environments but in cultures where people are more alienated or alone and are sit to units have to kind of be alone to lick their own wounds. I think that that's a culture that will not promote resilience in the same way. Because it's very hard to do that by yourself. It's hard to suffer and feel that nobody cares. Um, and when you are suffering maybe somebody does care. But if they're not right out there caring right? then and there. You won't see it and you might not know.

    24:10.52

    shefaflow

    So maybe we could speak maybe later or another time about improving the outcomes for Psychedelic assisted therapy with regards to ptsd and communal Contexts Um, but for now I'd really like to hear more.

    24:23.17

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, yes.

    24:28.12

    shefaflow

    Um, about Ptsd. So um, perhaps much like Ptsd Epigenetic Intergenerational trans-generational Trauma I don't know what term you prefer So I'll just throw them out. There is being used and especially in ah the environments where. Jews are talking about Psychedelic Assisted Therapy um either directed ah in medical context or self-directed um to describe their present experiences. The reason that they are experiencing what they experience in their minds and bodies is.

    25:05.71

    shefaflow

    Some degree as a result of what has been passed through those generations either through their parents or their grandparents that they are aware of and a lot of material which they are not because of just generational drift or. Displacement or you know for for me. For example I didn't know my great-grandparents and only had to do an incredible amount of research to even just know their names. Um, So what is important about understanding the genetic and epigenetic transmission and inheritance. Of these traits for people who are eager to heal and overcome them.

    25:48.24

    Rachel Yehuda

    Well, that's a really important question. Um the the study of epigenetics is still pretty recent. It's it's in its infancy I would say um, it's hampered by a lot of things. Um. 1 is that we haven't quite figured out how to do the research that shows us exactly how epigenetic marks even if you can measure them in people got there so we don't really know so we have 2 parallel conversations that are happening.

    26:19.32

    shefaflow

    Um.

    26:23.94

    Rachel Yehuda

    That kind of the zeitgeist is merging even though science isn't necessarily merging them. 1 is that you can measure epigenetic marks on on Dna. You can do that now. Technically um in human studies we do this in blood samples which may or may not. Um, inform us about processes in tissue other than blood right? So that's ah like a big ah big thing to to think about um and it's exciting that you can measure these things it's.

    26:49.65

    shefaflow

    Um.

    26:52.80

    shefaflow

    Okay.

    26:58.83

    Rachel Yehuda

    Super exciting when you measure a gene that is a stress related gene and you find an epigenetic change in a parent and also in a child I mean of course you're going to get excited about that. But we don't know how any of those epigenetic marks got there or what they really mean. Or whether we would see them again in two weeks if we looked again. We don't we don't know a lot of those things that's narrative one then there's this other narrative that's been going around for a long time which is.

    27:21.53

    shefaflow

    Um.

    27:30.91

    Rachel Yehuda

    Things that have happened to my parents and the generations before me are important and have molded me and that my life doesn't begin at my own conception or even birth I am carrying not just the Dna that. Tells me what color my eyes are going to be or how tall I'm going to be or what diseases I'm going to have god forbid I am I am also um, carrying around the sum total of ancestral experiences in some way now. Why do we believe this. Well if you're jewish It's really emphasized in the culture. Um from from the time that the first thing that many pafas are really taught is the manishanda passover seder where we say you know we were slaves to pharaoh in Egypt nobody who's jewish remembers that. Or thinks of themselves as being a slave to pharaoh in Egypt I mean nobody really, it's not really part of your identity but there's something about institutionalized religious practice in judaism that is designed to make you aware of ancestral experiences. Not for the purpose of traumatizing you for the purpose of showing you that you can overcome them that sitting here today. You're a long way off from that because you can overcome adversity even if it's really bad adversity.

    28:48.40

    shefaflow

    Um.

    29:02.27

    Rachel Yehuda

    And then the joke is and then let's eat you know, but it's really a powerful way of honoring it making space for it acknowledging it and hopefully being able to move forward from it. So I view the epigenetic work in a very in a very similar way. If I do have a biologic imprint. Let's say of some of an ancestral experience even Traumatic. What's it doing there is it there to traumatize me or is it there for me to have a tool is it there for me to understand that I have.

    29:27.17

    shefaflow

    Um.

    29:41.30

    Rachel Yehuda

    Power of transformation and change and adaptation because I think that is I think that's the more powerful cultural lesson and yes in order to have that you have to sort of accept as a reality that. Suffering but I sound too buddhist about it but you can't question why you suffer the suffering has to be well that's going to happen. So now when it happens am I equipped and I think in the Western What happens in the Western Framework is that we get all upset if adversity occurs.

    30:10.43

    shefaflow

    Um.

    30:17.58

    Rachel Yehuda

    Because what's that about I mean somebody must have promised me a rose garden but I'm not sure anyone really did and so I think the idea of Ancestral Wisdom is you can get through it and when many people do psychedelics. I Know this is true for me. You hear an ancestor saying it's ok, you could do this. It was hard for me too. I did it. You can do it? Um I'll be with you as you do it maybe or or um, we've all.

    30:48.49

    shefaflow

    Me.

    30:53.93

    Rachel Yehuda

    Been through something and and have come out and you can come out too but something that but most people under psychedelics don't get retraumattized by an ancestral trauma history. They ah kind of. Understand it and make peace with it or find some comfort in the fact that the person who is no longer here is in their consciousness in some way offering them something that is like a reassurance or a soothing or a strengthening. Or um, um, ah, spiritual channeling so again I like to think about intergenerational effects as a way of carrying something that is important. Um because experience is important. And Epigenetics describes the way that experience um, can imprint in your in your body making those experiences important and then.

    31:59.21

    shefaflow

    Um, this.

    32:03.70

    Rachel Yehuda

    We have to do the work. We talk about a lot about the work in psychedelics. What what does this work. You speak of you know, but the work is what am I going to do with it. How am I gonna what what am I going to do with this ancestral gift or this ancestral wisdom or this ancestral Burden or this ancestral legacy.

    32:15.86

    shefaflow

    Um, let me.

    32:21.99

    Rachel Yehuda

    How am I going to make it work for myself and increasingly I think you know there are some periods where people are very assimilated and some people were some periods where people say no I'm going back to my roots and there's kind of this pendulum that swings. Um, of now I don't I can't remember who my parents were my grandparents were and another pendulum. This was's the other way. No no, no I hate to know where I really come from I need to know what I'm only made of and the experiences that make me.

    32:49.85

    shefaflow

    A.

    32:56.98

    shefaflow

    Well, you've uncovered ah kind of some layers of depth to your work that I could have assumed but never really heard you articulate yet? Um, but something you know, just going back to what you were sharing about. Um. Healing in ah in a in a collective environment. Um, but something maybe trans-historical or even going to what I've heard Roman Peliski from emory talk about as deep time that when we talk about the collective. There might be the. Imagined or the the mythic collective that can help support one and for us as jews we have that built in you. We just like you said you open up the haatta and it and there it is. It's ah um, starting at Genna you know from a ah. Ah, a very low and and difficult place to shavva to a place of of upright praise and and song. So I want to take that with me just to think about for people that um, who. Don't have access to their generational intergenerational resilience or their stories. Um for people for whom they are just getting in touch with their jewishness for the first time sometimes because of their psychedelic work and for for others who.

    34:26.67

    shefaflow

    Have a sense of this but and I've never really thought about their ancestral traditions as reminders of the the hardiness that they have we maybe just focus on the wound itself but on the capacity for healing. Um, that is embedded within the wound feels like us I know such a you've called it a gift. Um, but such ah, a powerful support through these things. So um I want to just understand then then what is the what is the. What does it mean to heal from ptsd through psychedelic use is it just to retell the story of trauma instead of going from victimization victimhood to something else. How does how does it transform both in. And the psyche and also potentially in in the Dna.

    35:23.40

    Rachel Yehuda

    Another profound question you have asked Rabbi um I think that healing from ptsd is very much like that. It's it's kind of retelling the story um, from the perspective that it can end. Well. If it has't now it it can in the future and it it also means telling it in a way where you're not the villain of your story or the hero um in a way I mean one of the things that psychedelics do is promote self-compassion.

    35:58.76

    Rachel Yehuda

    And um, you'd be surprised how many trauma survivors blame themselves for what happened or have deep shame or humiliation or worthlessness or feel on some level they deserved what happened or they colluded with what happened all all sorts of things that end up.

    36:17.68

    Rachel Yehuda

    Expressing themselves as um that they feel like they're fundamentally bad or worthless. Um the opportunity of the psychedelic is to challenge that and to come come away with a very different. Sense of self if you can if if you have the right facilitation and and kind of the right set of circumstances. Um because the kind of work that you can do is really revisit your quote unquote role in the trauma and and. You know, a lot of us would rather feel that we did something wrong than that. The world is uncontrollable. It's just a much easier reality for us that you know we did something bad and that's why this happened I was so stupid if only I would have I wasn't strong enough etc. But the idea that no I couldn't have helped it I could not have done anything differently. Some things are bigger than me that is very very scary on an existential level that we are not always in Control. So I think the psychedelic process. Allows you to really go deep into some of these things and revisit them and and the other thing that happens is that you begin to feel more of a connection whether it's to who was in the room with you or your ancestors or your current family.

    37:50.47

    Rachel Yehuda

    Or your community society mother Nature God You don't feel like you're just a singular unit and that also to me is a very essential ingredient in healing. So I Think. Psychedelics can accelerate some of those things. Um, when I say that I really want to emphasize that that probably does not happen when you use them by yourself. Um, because part of part of this work. Does involve facilitation. Um, if you have ptsd it should be with a trained therapist that knows how to how to facilitate this for you and with you because some of the material can be very dark and upsetting and it can go bad before it gets good again and it's. Really not something that I personally like to think about people doing by themselves because what could go wrong. I'll be at home. Um, things can go wrong, but the idea is that if you have a chance to really Confront these ideas and deal with them.

    38:57.66

    shefaflow

    Um, right.

    39:06.21

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, then you can make a lot of progress. You can. You can kind of turn the narrative around of your life and um and a lot of people do.

    39:18.50

    shefaflow

    Well I'll um I'll tell you about a little gift that you gave me that I don't think that you could ever really know. But I heard you speak about this topic I mean already a couple years ago is during lockdown and I was listening to some. Interview that you had given at the time and just that just that idea about rewriting the narrative from the victim to the hero was enough for me in thinking about my own childhood and my own. Circumstances of my birth and and being raised that it was possible for me to in some ways. Step back inside those stories as ah as an adult and to I know coach. Young child to be present with the young child who was feeling hurt and neglected and confused about what was happening around them and I just want to thank you for for that. You know something that you said to someone somewhere and you didn't know where it would go it. It went straight into my heart and I think that's kind of one of the reasons that I have continued to reach out to you is you um you you gave me this.

    40:50.61

    shefaflow

    This thing that I can probably never repay in any way. So thank you for that.

    40:54.81

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, that's thank you. That's that's me something and is very very meaningful.

    41:03.21

    shefaflow

    Um, I wanted to just maybe wrap up our time. There's always so much more to to talk about at the moment of this recording um will be will be sharing this before pesach before passover but Friday of this past week in February of 2023 lychos therapeutics which is formerly the maps public benefit corporation announced Fda acceptance and priority review. Of a new drug application for mdma assisted therapy for ptsd. Can you tell people who are listening what does all of that mean and what does it mean for for Mdma Therapy moving forward.

    42:01.72

    Rachel Yehuda

    Ah sure I mean theoretically it means that we could see the fda approve Mdma assisted therapy and I hope it will be approved in conjunction with Psychotherapy Um, very soon. Which means that very soon Also people will be trained in how to do therapy with Psychedelic Medicine in Mainstream Mainstream settings that are often reimbursed by insurance and things like that. Um, right now. Most people who do psychedelics for healing do them out of the country or in the country underground with a shetleman or in a clinical trial or on their own but this will increase the availability of.

    42:57.74

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, of this this therapy so that it can you can go to a trusted medical center or a trusted clinic or doctor. And maybe get it. It. It won't be right away people have to learn how to do this a lot of people also don't want to see psychedelics medicalized but I would say to that is that if you don't have a psychiatric disorder I totally hear you. But if you do then you do want to take psychedelics in the construct within the construct of of ah of a medical environment that is responsible and really understands the risks involved in what can happen. When people are confronting traumatic material or things like that. So um, you know we sort of have this conversation where things get very obfuscated on the 1 hand you know a lot of people are using psychedelics that don't have a mental health condition. They're using it for a lot of different reasons. Maybe you don't need to use psychedelics in a medical context for those indications but the legalization and the approval of these drugs which make it easier to find people.

    44:27.76

    Rachel Yehuda

    That can help you and assist you and give you the right environment and take responsibility for um for the work that you do So I think it's a really good development. Um I think it'll take time for it to really filter in properly.

    44:46.12

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, but I'm happy about it. Yeah I'm happy about it again. Sometimes it takes more time than you want it to for things. Um.

    44:46.90

    shefaflow

    Um, azra hasham.

    44:56.10

    shefaflow

    That.

    45:00.95

    Rachel Yehuda

    But there's a lot involved in in kind of the rollout of this people in the psychedelic community may not feel. There's a shortage of psychedelic therapists. But the really there really is. There's a there's a shortage of mental health practitioners period. There's a shortage so I think. The good part is that medical schools and graduate schools and trade schools. You know therapy schools will start to teach people about this and maybe in five or ten years everybody will know about this. This will be kind of one of the things that people know and. That will be hopefully a time of ah, better healing. We do need healing I mean the things that are going on in this world right now really require some sort of a plan for our mental health and well-being.

    45:52.62

    shefaflow

    Well, we're drawing to a close in our time together and as this is being released in the month of Nissan for pesach I'm I'm wondering if maybe you want to to end with an idea from the the haggadah. Or something about pesach. Maybe something that your mother or father taught you that is is connected to your work in some way or just your spirit that you want to share with us.

    46:29.30

    Rachel Yehuda

    Um, well in in our Passover saders. We We did talk a lot about this idea of what what it? What freedom is what it means to really. Have freedom and carry a tradition and what it means to carry multiple traditions because one of the one of the beautiful things within the Hugga does that it intertwins different different kinds of of of um.

    47:03.99

    Rachel Yehuda

    Thoughts in them that come from different schools of thought. So I think that what's really very profound about the Passover experience is the idea of resilience redemption and of the fact that no matter. How dire your so your circumstances no matter where you start from, you can end up in a different place. Um, and ironically you do that not by running away from who you are but by carrying it with you. So that it is it. It isn't so much your Burden. It's it's It's more like your superpower.

    47:50.97

    shefaflow

    Dr. Rachel Yehuda thanks for talking with me in the ah.

    47:52.70

    Rachel Yehuda

    Thank you I accept now.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Mitchell Gomez

Lineage! Archaeology! Secret psychedelic histories! Drug policy and tikkun olam! Rabbi Zac receives the  Purim wisdom of altered states by Mitchell Gomez, executive director of ⁠DanceSafe⁠, a nonprofit health education and harm reduction organization based in Denver, CO.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠website here.⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

  • Mitchell Gomez is the Executive Director of DanceSafe, and a graduate of New College of Florida with a Masters from CU Denver. He has been a part of the electronic music community since the late 90’s, when he first started attending underground breaks shows while still in high-school and was helping to throw them by 2000. Mitchell has volunteered with the Burning Man organization, SSDP and other small harm reduction projects for many years, and is a passionate advocate for reality-based drug policy and harm reduction. In addition to his work with DanceSafe, Mitchell is a harm reduction consultant to the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies.

    Founded in 1999, DanceSafe has two fundamental operating principles: harm reduction and peer-based, popular education. Combining these two principles has enabled us to create successful, peer-based educational programs to reduce drug misuse and empower young people to make healthy, informed lifestyle choices. We are known for bringing adulterant screening (a.k.a., “pill testing,” “drug checking”) to the rave and nightlife community in the U.S., and for distributing unbiased educational literature describing the effects and risks associated with the use of various drugs. We also started the only publicly accessible laboratory analysis program for ecstasy in North America, currently hosted and managed by Erowid at EcstasyData.org. We neither condone nor condemn drug use. Rather, we provide a non-judgmental perspective to help support people who use drugs in making informed decisions about their health and safety.

  • 00:01.81

    shefaflow

    Um, where are you.

    00:11.85

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, boom.

    00:19.20

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, Denver or outside of Denver I live in the mountains and we are getting hammered with snow right now. So hopefully internet will be stable and if it's not we will deal with that as it happens. But yeah, it's ah it is really really coming down right now. Yeah.

    00:32.30

    shefaflow

    Boy how long have you been there.

    00:36.88

    Mitchell Gomez

    I've been in this house for 7 years um I was born in Colorado though. Um, and so yeah, my father's family was in San Louis Colorado when it was San Louis mexico so like the part of Mexico we're from is Colorado.

    00:53.63

    shefaflow

    Um, so I.

    00:55.40

    Mitchell Gomez

    Because they were running from the inquisition right? So you always wanted to be on the very edge of the empire. Um, so like founding family of Santa Fe and sixteen Eight ibeque in 1620 San Louis by seventy hundreds

    01:07.20

    shefaflow

    And then before that like Portugal or Spain proper. Yeah always gomez or was the there a name. A.

    01:12.36

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah, portugal Cobra always Gomez. It used to end with an s um they changed it to a z because s was a sephardic jewish spelling. Whereas ending it with a z meant that it was potentially just spanish right? So there's vanishingly few gomez is left that have it with an s because you know it was illegal to be if you could get out of portugal before they did the forced conversion. It was not illegal to be jewish right? But once they forced you to convert.

    01:47.95

    Mitchell Gomez

    Then if you continue to practice judaism then it was illegal and so yeah I have ah I have copies the originals are in Santa Fe but yeah one of my ancestors was arrested by the inquisition in Santa Fe ah for being a jew. Yeah.

    02:03.70

    shefaflow

    Wow. Um, so you missed that you missed the conversion you missed utter destruction. You kept moving the families kept moving. You know what did they? What did they hold onto.

    02:18.30

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, yeah I mean not a ton. Um, you know the there were always these sort of rumors in my father's side of the family. Um, but my father was raised very disconnected from both his sapharti Jewish heritage and also from his native American heritage right? So it was a.

    02:36.14

    Mitchell Gomez

    This is my theory but when you look at these families that were safati. Ah they very often married other families that might have been safati or native americans I think because it was safer than marrying a catholic right? So if you're a jewish man who's being raised secretly. Jewish. And you marry a native american woman hey once a year we both go to church right? You do your thing I do my thing we build a life together I think I really think that was part of the dynamic I do because if you look at their marriage records. It's shocking how often these crypto jew families were marrying into native american families. Um, it.

    03:10.36

    shefaflow

    So every ah the margins of white culture. Still you know, being able to mix and mingle and hang out with each other.

    03:15.34

    Mitchell Gomez

    Right? right? Um, and also always on the edge of the empire right? So you always you didn't want to be in Mexico City because then you would end up like the carva halls who I'm also a descendant of not ah Lewis de carva hall the main person who was. Like the center of that trial but his father's brother is one of my ancestors right? So I'm not He's not in my direct line but I do have Carva Hall ancestry and yeah, he I mean he had a little you know had a little prayer book they called they caught him with you know? so. That that side of the family There's no question like he was he went you know to his he was facing execution. He ended up throwing himself out of a ah window of the office of the inquisition is the story. Um, how how often the stories about suicide are true or how often the office of the inquisition use that to.

    03:59.90

    shefaflow

    Wow.

    04:08.41

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, explain away the fact that they had tortured someone to death which they were not supposed to do right? The whole idea is they could like torture you to confess but they weren't supposed to torture you to death. Um, but that's the story and yeah, they found his prayer book. He was very public about my family. My father was forced to convert. We never chose this I'm I'm a jew. Ah. And so yeah I have ah that Carva Hall ancestry as well and then my mother's family is ashkenazi. So I was primarily raised ah Ashkenazi I mean that was my father was so disconnected from his jewish ancestry that he actually did like a formal conversion process as an adult he wanted to. Be jewish again. Um, and so converted married my mother reconverted is a term that people are now starting to use in the 80 s that was not part of the narrative right? Um, but very much converted with this understanding of like there was this ancestry. Ah, so reconversion I think is appropriate right? I mean I think that's an appropriate terminology. Ah particularly when you're talking about people who didn't leave judaism right? they were. They were forced out of judaism. Um by what was arguably the most powerful government in the world at that time.

    05:08.14

    shefaflow

    Um, right.

    05:19.24

    Mitchell Gomez

    I mean the spanish and portuguese empire if you ever go to old churches in Portugal or Spain. Ah, you rapidly realize the idea that they owned half the world is not a joke like it's reflected in there the opulence of their churches from that time. Um, where you know. There's a reason that the majority of people who speak portugal are in Brazil right? There's far more portuguese speakers in the you know quote unquote new world than there are in Portugal and that's just a reflection of the fact that a bunch of guys in Europe Drew lines on a map and divided the world and it worked. I mean that's the I think that's the most astonishing thing is that it took so long to throw off that yoke of of colonial power. Um, you know I think there's countries in Africa that stopped being portuguese in french and italian colonies like in the sixty s like the 1960 s um, you know and so this was really the norm for just hundreds and hundreds of years is that this little section of Iberia Solarade you know where where jews had been since before the babylonian exile I mean those jewish communities don't date to the exile. These were traitors who had set up colonies in Europe. Ah, as part of like the spice trade and the wood trade and all of these things before before the exile and so yeah, if you look genetically at sepharta jews and theseai jews and ashknazi jews they form really distinct clusters right? They all share why Dna.

    06:49.21

    Mitchell Gomez

    Links to the levant I mean that's where you know all of our origins lie but we were separated for so long that. Ah, yeah, that's we're very distinct clusters except for those of us like me who you know were but but the missionh mash is happening now I think particularly in Israel right? I mean it's I don't think i.

    07:02.69

    shefaflow

    Yeah, the root part crewing the road. The roots start growing upwards and and out at some point for some.

    07:08.47

    Mitchell Gomez

    Oh yeah, yeah, what? what are those? What are those trees that do that the they're in Florida the cypress trees right? It's the.

    07:17.11

    shefaflow

    Yeah cypress so you this living cyrus of all of these histories and stories and ah your pockets of resilience and resistance. Um. And you know the first time that we met it was out here in San Francisco and you know the first thing that you asked me or you told me about was your time in Asia torah in Jerusalem like how did you get from Colorado and your lineage to studying Torah in this particular place.

    07:47.99

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, ah so my mother lived in Israel during the 60 s and seventy s um and so I grew up often hearing these stories. Ah and my mother's family. We have everything from reform jews I mean I I primarily grew up in like a reform synagogue. To ah haredi I mean like all the way as far as it as far as it goes and so I was exposed to a really broad swath of of judaism growing up right? I mean I would go spend I always thought of them as summers. But I know it was winters but I would go from Colorado to Miami to see my grandparents. And my memories were always of it being so hot that I thought I was spending my summers there but it was definitely winters that was I was going to Miami and so ah yeah I mean grew up around. Ah you know Miami jewish culture which obviously has everything right from humanistic judaism all the way to you know the sort of temple mount faithful level of.

    08:40.68

    shefaflow

    Death.

    08:42.68

    Mitchell Gomez

    Of ah of haredi like these these folks who think that we should destroy the dome of the rock and rebuild the third temple and they're building the third temple right? It's a collapsible building that is in warehouses in in Jerusalem. It's yeah, ready to go I mean I could put it up in a weekend.

    08:52.18

    shefaflow

    Ready to go.

    08:58.44

    Mitchell Gomez

    They're planning to put it up in a weekend right? I mean that's the reality and so yeah, when I when I turned 18 I I really wanted to go overseas I had some money from my bar mitzvah my parents very smartly. Um. Did not ah really let me touch most of that money. So some of it I had going through high school but the majority of it was thrown into a bank account that I did not have access to and I'm tremendously thankful for that because god knows what I would have spent it on. Um or maybe I would have spent it on magically gatherings cards and I you know have a million dollar magic collection I have no idea. Ah.

    09:32.19

    Mitchell Gomez

    So yeah I sold my sold my car I knew I was going for quite a long time and first went to Israel in 99 on a four month birthright program. So it was one of the longer Birthright programs. Ah they place you on a kibbutz. Um, you don't actually know which kibbutz until like a few days before you. Get to Israel like it's ah, really felt very last minute in my mind I'm not sure if that was the case or if that was an intentional decision to like not let you you know, dive too deeply before you landed. Ah. And so I ended up on kiba's from orhel which is right between jerusalem and Bethhelhem right? It's quite close to jerusalem probably walkable if you were a slightly different human than me I often did not walk I would take the bus. Ah.

    10:10.28

    shefaflow

    Um, and um.

    10:21.50

    Mitchell Gomez

    And so yeah I would spend a lot of my free time in both jerusalem and Bethlehem this was before the entirety of the wall was built right? This was pre second intifada. There was some security infrastructure between jerusalem and Bethlehem I do remember having to go like through. But I think that was mostly around.

    10:27.39

    shefaflow

    Print.

    10:38.14

    Mitchell Gomez

    Private property issues I don't think it was like the security wall I remember tall fences but I don't remember like the concrete wall that trip. Um, and so yeah I would like often walk into Bethlehem or take the bus into jerusalem. Ah.

    10:55.00

    Mitchell Gomez

    And at the time you know I'd been bar mitzvahd of course and like you know I grew up in this family. Ah I didn't really think of myself as particularly religious I mean jewish morality still to this day like is the fundamental core of of who I am and how I navigate the world and what I believe. Ah, but I didn't think of myself as particularly religious I went to synagogue because my mother was the president of the hebrew day school. It was not really an option to not go to synagogue obviously um, but you know I have this memory of on yom kippur like sneaking out to walk to the burger King and just like the entire thing was filled with people from our synagogue right? I mean it was like it's. And like people who were like ah publicly quite religious. It was ah really a moment of of a realization that you can't.

    11:35.57

    shefaflow

    Yeah, was that comforting or was that like as ah as a child looking at hypocrisy.

    11:43.39

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah I think a little bit of both. Um I think you know the idea that ah being in community sometimes requires a compromise on your public and private life.

    11:57.40

    shefaflow

    Ah.

    11:57.49

    Mitchell Gomez

    Depending on the community. But that's true of most communities right? There's generally most communities. There's some sort of compromise that takes place between your private and public life. Um, and I don't know if that's necessarily hypocrisy I think it can be um I Also think that that's just.

    12:11.80

    shefaflow

    Yeah, yeah.

    12:15.57

    Mitchell Gomez

    How humans relate to the world right? Um, you know there's ah I forget that who wrote it but there's some science fiction story about you know humans all developing telepathy for a day and it like destroys society right? like suddenly this ability to like know what a person's true. Inner thoughts are like completely demolishes the nature of society and.

    12:32.50

    shefaflow

    Sure.

    12:35.29

    Mitchell Gomez

    I Think that's largely true I don't think society could survive. Um, if all humans became telepathic for a day I think that would be a tremendous problem for the vast majority of people in every given culture. Um.

    12:47.56

    shefaflow

    Yeah I met meant just the the hypocrisy of a child sometimes you know seeing things in in more ah ah, binaries and not necessarily the the the sophisticated nuance that you're sharing. But.

    12:59.49

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah I I was raised in a family that I think really Values Nuance Binary thinking is not a thing that my parents really tolerated much as I was growing up. Um, you know they sent me to a lab school from Kindergarten through.

    13:07.23

    shefaflow

    Um.

    13:16.62

    Mitchell Gomez

    Fourth grade So they don't There's not a lot of them. It was ah a brilliant idea one that I wish had expanded but Lab schools are basically kindergarten through college on a single campus. Um, and even the kindergartners are being. Ah, oh.

    13:18.74

    shefaflow

    And.

    13:30.56

    shefaflow

    Okay, just making a note around the 13 minute Mark that Mitch has kind of glitched out. Okay.

    13:35.40

    Mitchell Gomez

    Oh I lost you hold on hold on oh in my back am I back Hello hello.

    13:49.59

    shefaflow

    Um, we'll see what his status is coming back coming back looking good. Yeah I'm here him can you hear me.

    14:14.26

    shefaflow

    I'm I'm here. Can you hear me great. That's all good. No, it's so like 13 minute Mark um, your parents wouldn't tolerate binary thinking much more nuanced and then.

    14:15.00

    Mitchell Gomez

    Are we back? Yeah I can hear you now sorry about that where did where did I drop off.

    14:30.19

    shefaflow

    The freeze So we we'll edit it and it's all good.

    14:32.49

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, perfect. Um, yeah so I perfect? Um, yeah, so growing up as a child my parents sent me to a lab school. Um, which yeah, um, a thing that I really would love to see expanded in this country seems unlikely, but it's kindergarten through college on a single campus.

    14:37.18

    shefaflow

    Yeah, Lab school. Yeah.

    14:50.25

    Mitchell Gomez

    All of the teachers are college teachers. So even in kindergarten I had college professors in our in our classrooms often very self-directed learning if you were interested in something they would encourage you to just like dive as deeply into it as you possibly could and so yeah, grew up really in a sort of. Intellectually curious environment where I was encouraged to sort of be as adult as I wanted to be and then my dad got a job in Florida and I got dropped into a public school in Florida in the fifth grade and it was a bit of a problem I don't think I ever actually fully. Ah.

    15:10.86

    shefaflow

    Um.

    15:15.38

    shefaflow

    Wow! the.

    15:23.87

    Mitchell Gomez

    Recovered from that Intel college when I went to New College of Florida which has a similar sort of you can create your own degrees or had now that you know Desantis is trying to basically destroy it. But at the time you could create your own degrees. You could create your own class classes. You could create your own programs of study and in the founding Docs of new college.

    15:29.19

    shefaflow

    Right.

    15:43.60

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, is this principle that in the final analysis. Every student is responsible for their own education and so it was really from fifth grade till college I was missing that but that was a part of my very young life and then a part of my college career as well and it really is ah.

    16:00.13

    Mitchell Gomez

    An idea worth diving into um for how we run education. Ah.

    16:03.24

    shefaflow

    Ah, so with this background and you know hopping between bethlehem and downtown Jerusalem and the old city.

    16:09.49

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, um, yes I went to the the kotel and the kotel got me right? The guys who asked have you ra to fillin today I I had not I had not in fact, rapped to fill in in probably I think the entire three four months I'd been in Israel I had not been in a synagogue I had not. Really prayed. So I did and ended up speaking for quite a long time with somebody who was there but wasn't there with the guys asking to wrap the fill in we just sort of connected and started talking ah at the time he was quite a young.

    16:45.42

    shefaflow

    Who.

    16:45.79

    Mitchell Gomez

    Rabbi not really established. Not really well known but it was yomov glazier and so by sort of pure happenstance ended up in this long conversation with Yom Tov who as a sort of well-des deserveved reputation as like a relatively psychedelic human like speaking with him is sort of a consciousness altering experience. He grew up sort of in hippie community still surfs so you know the surfing Rabbi although now much more the singing rabbi.

    17:06.92

    shefaflow

    This is.

    17:17.21

    Mitchell Gomez

    And is one of those people who I genuinely believe if we all gain telepathy for a day. Not a single thought about him would change I think he is privately and publicly the same person like that is who he is. Ah, and I I find that you know obviously you never know what's going on in another person's mind but ah, he's a really deep and interesting and mystical human who I really enjoyed spending time with and so when it came time for the end of my ah time at the at kios restaurant royal hell. You know I was dumb picking apples. Um and and making desserts in the hotel. Those are my two Keywiz jobs. Ah I actually I found a like a three week archeology program where you could volunteer on a dig so I was doing that for a few weeks ahtalmaishia which is a really.

    17:51.34

    shefaflow

    Um, so beautiful.

    18:03.39

    shefaflow

    This.

    18:10.65

    Mitchell Gomez

    Very unknown but really awesome archeological site. They often find. Ah no, it's northern I believe it was a long time ago. But I think it's a little north um, because it's one of the areas where they find evidence of oshara worship quite late into the second temple period.

    18:11.90

    shefaflow

    Where's that exactly outside of Jerusalem. Okay.

    18:28.53

    Mitchell Gomez

    So in very very early judaism. The evidence is now quite strong that ah god had a wife right? There was ah ah alshara was was his wife. It was during the hezekiah reforms that that was really like stamped out by Hezekiah who was trying to centralize worship in Jerusalem. He destroyed all of these like rural temples.

    18:41.51

    shefaflow

    Yeah, we have textual evidence and it's corroborated by the archeological record. Don't get that so often.

    18:47.81

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um.

    18:54.60

    Mitchell Gomez

    And also when you when you read the torah and you separate out the storylines right? There's the ah you hey valpes storyline and then the elohim storyline. There are clearly 2 different narratives that are mashed together in the torah. And in the elohim storyline you ah you don't see claims of monotheism you see claims of monolateralism right? You could only worship one god but you never see a denial of the existence of other gods. Um, writing even elolal great.

    19:13.50

    shefaflow

    But.

    19:19.66

    shefaflow

    Yeah, we have that and't and this week's partsha right? and we're recording during partshha basalah. But we're recording for purra you meet kamoha ba alim a nay who is like you amongst the alim amongst the the divine. Retinue meaning the existence of the retinue is is right there but only that yohe vavhe stands above all of them.

    19:40.79

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, right? yeah right? And ah yeah, the for anyone who's interested in this I know we're getting way off the subject but the bible and.

    19:51.14

    shefaflow

    And no, it's good.

    19:56.89

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, the bible on earth is a spectacular book on ah the sort of archaeological evidence of how judaism changed over time ah within the sort of indigenous development within canon because it's. Quite clear that this was a local religious movement right? We did not. You don't see any evidence in the archaeological record of like a jewish invasion into canan even though that is the narrative that was presented by the hezekiah reforms right? That narrative was written quite late in judaism um, and. Doesn't really match the historical evidence and I find all of this so fascinating for a lot of reasons. Ah but 1 of the big ones is that figuring out what judaism has meant over time I think allows us a window into what we wish to be judaism. Right? At this point I substantially consider myself a humanistic jew I you know I believe in the principles and the moral foundations of judaism. Ah I am obviously far less convinced of the sort of divine authorship or inspiration of the torah I think that the torah was. A product of a specific time and place and a specific political agenda right? I mean it's a political treaty by Hezekiah about why worship should be centralized in Jerusalem. Ah presents an image of the size of the kingdom of judea that is almost certainly just historically not true.

    21:21.72

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, ju um, you know there was clearly a judean kingdom I mean we find evidence all the time but we find it in Jerusalem and the environs right? We don't find evidence of this judean kingdom in Iraq right? which is like what the the textual claim is within the torah is that it was. You know, basically the euphrates out and so we don't find any evidence of that and so yeah, it's we havent yet we haven't yet and god knows if they found something if if iraqi archaeologists found something in Iraq I do not know if that would be public information in the same way that if we found evidence of ah.

    21:42.43

    shefaflow

    We haven't yet we haven't yet. But yeah, ah.

    21:55.94

    shefaflow

    Yeah, of course.

    21:57.73

    Mitchell Gomez

    The things I'm talking about right about Hezekiah doing these edits I'm not hundred percent sure how that would trickle out either if it was found in the current political climate within Israel and so yes, but yes I think that the reading the torah as a document that is a product of a time and place is appropriate.

    22:01.80

    shefaflow

    Sure.

    22:16.45

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, but also I think that you know reading the massive body of Jewish literature that has grown up around the Torah that deals far more with ethics than the Torah itself often does right? I mean the Torah is ah. Often more a history book and a law book. It doesn't really dive deeply into the why the why is because has I'm said to right? I mean that's the sort of extent of the of of the why often within the within the Torah but you know we have all of these mutualhi that are I genuinely believe this I. The greatest sort of self-contained moral code that has been developed by man so far it is a moral code that if followed does provide tremendous value both to the individual and to community as a whole. And so even though I I you know I I mean I you know I have Mo this is on my doors I consider myself a jew you know I don't pray over my food before I eat right? Um, although it is a practice that I've actually been considering sort of.

    23:15.63

    shefaflow

    Your.

    23:26.86

    Mitchell Gomez

    Reincorporating mostly as a mindfulness practice around ah the remembrance that even as a vegetarian. Ah my sustenance causes harm right? like the way that we run agriculture my ability to eat causes harm to the world. Ah, and so as a sort of mindfulness practice around the importance of remembering that our our mere existence creates harm and so we have an obligation to mitigate that harm by providing value to the world I think is a really powerful practice and one that we again. That's not a. That's not a modern take on on jewish existence right? This idea that god created the world and then handed it to humanity right? whereas within the christian tradition. There's sort of this idea that like god is the caretaker of the world. Um. This is one of the many areas where there really is no judeo-christian tradition. There's a there's a judeo islammic tradition right? Judaism and islam agree perfectly on this point that the the world was created and then the stewardship of the world was given to humanity. Ah, it. This is I think actually interestingly one of the areas where I didn't realize as I moved into harm reduction. How deeply judaism was informing my beliefs around drug policy and harm reduction. But this is one of those areas where I think it really shows up right? I mean the fact that faults and prayers within judaism without action is a sin.

    24:59.77

    Mitchell Gomez

    But you don't get to just pray about a problem. You actually have a moral obligation to fix the problem or you have sinned ah hold on I can do this problem. The batta law is that this is that is and yeah, yeah, there we go all? Well it's been a long time since yeshiva.

    25:07.43

    shefaflow

    You got it? Yeah brush. Yeah yeah, you're doing great. You.

    25:18.57

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, and so yeah, Ah, if you the immediate commandment is if you make a prayer over food and then you don't immediately eat the food. You've you've sinned ah but that principle like everything in Judaism right? here's the specific. You can't cook ah a baby goat in his mother's milk. And now suddenly we build a fence around this right and suddenly you can't use the same dishes for meat and cheese from that original principle of not cooking a goat in its mother's milk which to me actually reads as a prohibition against Needless cruelty. Right? Like that's how it reads to me and always has not as a dietary restriction. The restriction is actually on being needlessly cruel. But this idea that. Ah oh we have this problem in society like we'll just like let we'll let God take care of it. We'll let government take care of it. Right? Doesn't fly in Judaism we each as individuals. Once we have identified a problem within society ah are commanded to work towards its resolution both because of ah tikun alarm but also because of this idea of of ah. You can't do a blessing without doing the thing and blessings in Judaism have always read to me as not so much. Ah, an axe an ask for intercession from the divine.

    26:41.60

    Mitchell Gomez

    I mean I think that's how in a christian we're all raised in the the milieu of christianity in America whether or not we were raised jewish um, and when people say like oh I had I prayed for this or I blessed this ah in christianity you are asking the divine for direct interce intercession.

    26:57.33

    shefaflow

    Intercession. Yeah.

    26:59.51

    Mitchell Gomez

    Direct Involvement Yeah direct involvement in the thing in Judaism. That's not really what prayers are right? I mean the prayers are our reminder our acknowledgement of ah Hashem has created this thing and we are now able to use it to survive. And so we are simply acknowledging the reality that I'm doing the Yeshiva hand thing as soon as they start talking about Juism about you. Never do this on any other side I Gett into judaism. Yeah yeah I get into Judaism and I then ah yeah, but it's this acknowledgement of ah.

    27:18.58

    shefaflow

    I Love it I'm loving it man you're you're you're having a full blown somatic experience.

    27:35.53

    Mitchell Gomez

    The connection between us as individuals the world as the place which allows us as individuals to exist and a reminder that because we have been blessed right? We are not blessing the food. We have been blessed with the food. And so that's really the direction of of ah of brahold within judaism of Prayers within Judaism. Ah yeah.

    27:57.15

    shefaflow

    Yeah, and even the the statement of the statement of need and the admission of lack regardless of of where the fulfillment of it comes from to be able to express one's needs as having um value and there's. The dignity enough that one's needs could be fulfilled and and and asked for feels like a regardless of where one is with regards to the power of divinity humanist or otherwise could also be a very just ah, a powerful notion and practice.

    28:30.88

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah I think just in general as a species I think it's easy for us to go to autopilot right? It's easy for us to sort of start moving through the world without thinking about the world. Ah, and.

    28:43.15

    shefaflow

    Of people.

    28:48.24

    Mitchell Gomez

    The Torah and and therashima around it and you know the whole thing the whole system of judaism. Um, at its heart is a focusing lens on our need to provide value to the world. Ah.

    29:07.40

    Mitchell Gomez

    Or obligation ah to provide value to the world and it's something that existed so deeply within my consciousness this idea that we have an obligation to repair the world that I didn't really connect it to how I had been. Academically and professionally moving towards ending drug harms. Um, but the more I've you know this is ah I've been you know I've spoken about this a few times now there is the jewish psychedelic conference a few years ago which I believe is how we first became aware of each other was that that was through that jewish pychedelic conference if I'm remembering correctly i.

    29:42.38

    shefaflow

    Um, yeah.

    29:45.67

    Mitchell Gomez

    It Really it really is like this idea of Tikun Alum ah sits really really deeply in how I think about drugs and drug harms and the ideas around pickco and fesh right? This idea that within Judaism we have not only the ability but the. Requirement to break any law to save a life right? This is not just a not just ah, an option. It is a commandment. Ah.

    30:12.54

    shefaflow

    Right? Even something as severe as Shabbat if you see that someone is in threat of losing their life One can basically um, cast off every every mitzvah every commandment in order to save that person's life.

    30:30.41

    Mitchell Gomez

    Right? And ah, you know obviously within judaism its vote are are much higher obligations than temporal governmental laws right? And so if we have an obligation to break any mitzvah or any prohibition. To save a life certainly we are required to violate ah the laws of man to save a life and so you know the fact that many of the services that are provided within harm reduction are not legal. Right? I mean there are underground safe use facilities all over this country people who are running spaces where people can come and use opiates under you know, quasi medical supervision that is a crime and as a jew I have no choice but to view that as. A justified violation of the law because of baginavish you know the test kits are considered drug paraphernalia in 30 some odd states right? I might be the most arrestable person in drug policy like if a da really wanted to push this issue. It would be very very easy to order a test kit file an arrest warrant. And I would be happy to have this conversation in front of a jury right about my religious and moral obligation to save a life. Ah, and I've never been able to find any historical evidence of this but within western common law. There is this idea of a necessity defense.

    31:55.54

    Mitchell Gomez

    And I think this may have come from judaism because it seems unlikely to have come from christianity and so it's this idea that if you broke a law to save a life within this is Us law all the way back to british common law. That's how old this principle is ah. It is an affirmative defense in court. It does not prevent you from being arrested or charged but is a thing you can say to a jury as yes I broke the law my defense for that breaking of the law is that it was required to save a life this shows up most often when people run red lights to get to hospitals right? This is a necessity defense within.

    32:25.39

    shefaflow

    And.

    32:31.30

    Mitchell Gomez

    That behavior if you were running a red light to get somebody to a hospital because the level of emergency rose to that severity. You can prevent. You can present that in court. As a reason why running that red light was not actually illegal and so yeah, that's always been the plan. It just seems vanishingly unlikely and less likely every year it's going to come up. Ah, the fentanyl adulteration crisis has really changed the conversation around drug checking and changed the conversation around harm reduction in a way that actually makes me quite uncomfortable. We should have been proactive around this right when it was poor. Ah you know people of color primarily dying from opiates that conversation was not happening. Um, you know the idea that we would open safe use facilities was talked about as like enabling junkies right? I mean that was the the language. Um and now that it's like rich white kids dying from fentanyl and cocaine. Suddenly it's not an epidemic. It's ah or not a scourge It's an epidemic right? It's moved into like this public health language. Ah.

    33:10.52

    shefaflow

    I.

    33:22.63

    shefaflow

    Right? right? crisis right.

    33:28.41

    Mitchell Gomez

    Although I will say that the response from Public Health My dog is insisting I open this door for her. We will get continue this. It's up you yes I know like very hard. Yeah, yeah, and we can also I don't I don't believe I have a hard stop time. Let me just make sure.

    33:31.48

    shefaflow

    It's okay, yeah, go for it. We're pausing at 33 minutes and 30 seconds until the dog is let in.

    33:45.88

    shefaflow

    It's okay sweetie okay all good. It's okay.

    33:46.60

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, let's see she just wanted to open the door to walk out three feet and turn around I just heard her walk back in the room. Um yeah I do not have a hard stop time so because I know we got a little and a little bit of a late start. Um, yeah, ah, but yes, what I was saying is this. This language shift that has happened despite the fact that there has not been a commensurate policy shift right? We have not yet seen the public health officials certainly at the federal level um, navigate this in the way that I think it needs to be navigated i. I love drug checking as a service I love setting up at events and testing people's drugs. It's super fun. It provides a really good window to talk about drugs in a super honest way and it is also just literally shoveling the ocean with a fork when it comes to misrepresentation. This is a. All drug deaths combined the numbers are not yet out for 2023 but I've seen the trends and I've seen some of the preliminary data and I think for 2023 we will have lost 3 times as many people to drug deaths as we did to aids in the peak year of the h iv crisis.

    34:48.80

    shefaflow

    And.

    34:52.50

    Mitchell Gomez

    We were talking about a massive public health crisis. Ah for people under the age of 40 drug deaths were the leading cause of death in all fifty states during covid right? like during a separate massive public health crisis that was killing people. Drugs were still the leading cause of death for people under the age of 40 in all 50 states. It is the leading cause of death overall in some states which is astonishing when you look at the sort of age demographics of our population and the sort of aging boomer generation which is now starting to pass away. Ah. This is not a thing that nonprofits can fix like period. Ah, that doesn't mean we shouldn't try in the same way that nonprofits probably cannot fix homelessness right? That doesn't mean you don't have nonprofits addressing the problem. But what I am saying is that the scale of the problem of drug adulteration and drug misrepresentation and drug debts. Overall. Is one that requires a coordinated federally funded public health response. Um, and ultimately I don't think it is solvable without not just decriminalization but the legalization of drug sales I think that providing people with the drugs they want through some sort of regulated model. Ah, is likely our only way out of this ah which is a politically heavy lift right? The idea that we're going to sell cocaine and heroin um through some sort of regulated whether that's I don't think having it be as like a for profit system the way that cannabis was done is appropriate at all I'm not asking to see Cocaine billboards.

    36:23.20

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, as funny as it would be right? but that's not what I'm asking for? Yeah yeah, f float is ready to go right? I mean there's you got that highway coming out of Miami across the alligator alley like just but you know it's good to go and like honestly.

    36:24.16

    shefaflow

    Ah, Florida your home state sounds like a um.

    36:37.76

    Mitchell Gomez

    For that city they might as well I don't think it would increase use any in Miami I think everyone who is in Miami who wants to use cocaine today is using cocaine today and so I don't think prohibition actually does anything when it comes to affecting use. Actually that's not true I think there's probably a small percentage of people who just don't do things that aren't legal. Um, I do think that if we legalize drug sales across the board. We would see a small increase in use I don't actually care about the number of people who use drugs I care about drug harms right in the same way that I don't care who a person marries right? like that is just not. A sphere of influence in another person's life that I believe is an appropriate use of state power and I feel the exact same way about drug use I simply don't think it is an appropriate use of state power to tell people what drugs they can consume what drugs they can purchase what drugs they can sell i. And as we've seen the sort of secondary harms of prohibition just vastly outweigh any possible benefit that we receive from these policies not just in the sphere of adulteration misrepresentation in the suppression of religious liberty. Right? I mean there was a rabbi in Denver who was using psilocybin as part of his practice. Um I believe very sincerely I do not think this was in any way performative I think this was a so a sincere religious belief who was arrested and ultimately I don't believe went to jail but had to spend oh it did not perfect. Good to hear. Um I thought that was my understanding.

    37:57.92

    shefaflow

    Did not. Yeah, yeah.

    38:06.43

    Mitchell Gomez

    But spent a tremendous amount of money defending his religious beliefs and in this country you should not have to raise money to defend your religious beliefs from government interference that is a very core principle of this country and I cannot imagine any world in which an adult using psilocybin as part of their religious practice. Is somehow more harmful than a person raising their child to be like a young earth creationist right? The harm to the world from the second act is far greater than the harm to the world of the first and yet you would never hear an american politician suggest using police power. To like seize these children and force them into public education where realistically they would receive a far better education than they are from somebody who's teaching them that Satan Hid dinosaur bones during the flaw or you know, whatever the whatever the current narrative is from from these young earth creationists who clearly don't read Hebrew. Because if you read Hebrew and you read genesis there is just no question that is this is not. It was never intended as a literal story like that is textually clear from the the evidence this was meant as metaphor and allegory and ah storytelling right? I mean it was storytelling. Around our innate desire as humans to have a ah narrative of where we come from? Um, but like yeah.

    39:24.57

    shefaflow

    Um, so maybe if we could talk about storytelling a little bit for a second. Um, we're we're um, other than you like the story of dance safe and all of the information about the organization that you are stewarding will be available for people to check out I really wanted to get your. Um, to your your read specifically about um the holiday of purim and um the the mitzvah the obligation of drinking and at the same time. Ah the other voices that are trying to.

    39:50.77

    Mitchell Gomez

    Oh so.

    40:01.59

    shefaflow

    Um, Mitigate or reduce harm in this particular ritual ecstatic act. So I'm sure that you have thought about some of this before. Um and I'm wondering like where where is your where is your mind.

    40:13.26

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah.

    40:18.46

    shefaflow

    To this these days.

    40:21.29

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah, so first I want to tell my favorite ah kabbalistic story about purim I've ever heard and then we can dive in deeply so I had a rabbi in in Israel. Ah.

    40:28.47

    shefaflow

    Great.

    40:37.27

    Mitchell Gomez

    Who would often sort of drop little pieces of of Kabbalistic knowledge. Even though they're That's not really supposed to happen until you're much much older than I was at the time and have studied the Torah much more deeply. Um it it does seem to all be gone. It does seem to be that like.

    40:42.67

    shefaflow

    Um, yeah, they've paused that it's all good now. Yeah, ah.

    40:50.94

    Mitchell Gomez

    I mean when you can buy the ah ah the zillhar on Amazon right? It's like where where is that where' is the the line here right? I mean books used to be a controllable thing and now that is just not the the case anymore. Ah and he told me that there was a secret meaning to the name yom kippur.

    40:51.16

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    41:08.21

    Mitchell Gomez

    Which is that the real name of yom kippur is yom kippurim, it's a day like purim a date almost as holy as purim and the main sort of narrative of purim is that you are supposed to become so intoxicated that you lose the narrative. But you can no longer tell the difference between the good guy and the bad guy in the story and that is the commandment is to become that um, intoxicated and the reason is that at its heart judaism although started as monolateralist and became monotheistic. Much of judaism is actually non-dualistic right? Ah, the the Shama does not read in hebrew as a claim of monotheism it claims as a reed of non-d duality god is one not there is only one god right? You could say that in Hebrew and that is not what the shaal says. Shamal says god is one and at one point I asked a ah Rabbi about this about this because I had studied hinduism and in high school and so I was worried I was imposing this sort of like odd by Dantic you know misread on the shama.

    42:15.61

    shefaflow

    Oh.

    42:24.44

    Mitchell Gomez

    And I asked him you know to me the shamaah now reads more and more as a claim of Non-d Duality not a claim of monotheism and I'll never forget he said he said he didn't say me he said moshe So it mosha own is my my other name. Ah and he said moshe.

    42:37.96

    shefaflow

    Um, good good.

    42:42.94

    Mitchell Gomez

    How could anything exist outside of the infinite like what do you think infinite means and so the emporium we're supposed to live our lives most of the year three hundred and sixty four days out of the year as if things like good and evil are real as if ah. It's volta are real as if prohibitions are real but one day a year we are commanded to become so altered that we remember the ultimate truth which is god is one ah, but that's just not a useful way of navigating the world right? like living. These non-dualalistic avidontic communities in India you're only allowed to join them once you've had a family and had a child right? You can't as a young person move into these like you know, shavi sadu oddvidontic communities because once you do you're not navigating the world anymore. You are just living in godhood god mind. Um, and so yeah, that's that's my favorite story about for him. Ah.

    43:41.47

    shefaflow

    As a beautiful story about purum and you so in there you mentioned there's this um the the commandment for drinking on purum does not necessarily come from the book of esther itself. Although drinking is ah the I think the the major the main character of. Of the story but something actually from the babylonian talmud I believe it's in the massehet the tracate of maggiah and it opens up with a statement and says a person is obligated to become intoxicated on purum. Until they are so intoxicated that they don't know how to distinguish between a saying of which is cursed is haman cursed is the the main antagonist that like you said the bad guy of the story and the saying blessed is Mordechai one of the heroes of the story. So that's where. That idea comes hi of enish the visume a person is obligated to drink that much until the binary of good evil Mordechai Hamman melts away.

    44:48.45

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, and you know there's more and more evidence now of ah psychedelic use within the ancient world right? The eleusian mysteries now is entirely uncontroversial. That's a maybe 4 hour boat ride from haifa. Right? We are not talking massive distances. There's evidence of psychedelic use within ancient egyptian culture particularly their mystery schools probably used high dose lotus or maybe some sort of ergot preparation. Ah, and I know this is a really controversial belief. Um, but I think the evidence for psychedelic use within early judaism is also quite strong I yeah I one of the biggest pieces to me is ah the showbred right? This bread that the high priest would consume within the holy of holies to commune with god ah.

    45:22.95

    shefaflow

    Strong. Oh.

    45:41.25

    Mitchell Gomez

    Which in Hebrew with bread of faces is like another valid sort of way that you can read that like I can't think of a better description of a psychedelic cracker than the bread of faces like that's just like yep, that's what I would call that psychedelic cracker ah, and I believe it is in Deuteronomy where if a woman is accused of adultery. She is taken to the temple and given the threshings of the showbread right? that the sort of stuff on the floor from when you made the showbred and if she is innocent of adultery she will have this transcendent vision of of angels. Although I think they're.

    46:14.45

    shefaflow

    The.

    46:20.25

    Mitchell Gomez

    Angels is the english translation I think they're actually the I forget the name the chair that Ezekiel right? Not there. It's not a living. Yeah yeah, um, and if she's guilty. Ah her limbs will turn dark and she'll die which is a description of ergot poisoning right? and this is not like in some sort of like in that.

    46:22.10

    shefaflow

    Yeah, the Miracle Va yeah.

    46:36.20

    shefaflow

    I.

    46:38.68

    Mitchell Gomez

    Tall motor in the me draw she like this is core texturual torah description of ergot poisoning from somebody consuming the showbread I also further think that the showbread was widely used by all jews before the Hezekiah reforms his attempt to centralize worship within the priesthood. I think is when the use of this psychedelic sacrament was sort of like phased out of judaism I think it's why he destroyed all of the other temples because they knew how to make the the bread of faces or another better translation than showbread is the bread which shows. Right? So the the bread that the bread that can show you the bread that we are explicitly told priests would consume in the holy of holies to speak directly to hashan right? I mean to speak directly to god. Ah.

    47:35.91

    Mitchell Gomez

    And the story of purim reads to me as first of all a much older tradition than the persian cultural narrative which was imposed on top of it right? I think that the way folklore study folklore is really useful in this context where you don't look at the names of the characters. You don't look at the claimed time and place because those change. But the larger sort of narrative structure of stories is how folklorists classify folklore because obviously if I was telling a story to a child now I likely would not set it in ancient Persia right? I would set it at their high school and so these stories change over time. Ah, we're seeing this with Yucca Mountain where we're storing our radioactive weights that's going to last for maybe millions of years where they're into folklorists about how do we create cultural narrative not specific language not specific imagery.

    48:16.83

    shefaflow

    Friends.

    48:28.27

    Mitchell Gomez

    Cultural narrative to describe that area as dangerous because we need it to become folklore because it's going to survive far longer than english will survive as a language. It will be radioactive thousands of hundreds of thousands of years after english is no longer around and so you do it.

    48:30.75

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    48:41.88

    shefaflow

    I Heard that one of those ah one of those ideas was also to institute like a a nuclear priesthood in order to yeah ah.

    48:49.58

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah, religion and folklore right? or genetically modified cats with glowing eyes and then creating cultural stories about glowing cats being dangerous is a real proposition and form a federal government document. That's a real thing. It's like well genetically engineer glowing eye cats.

    49:01.53

    shefaflow

    Ah.

    49:08.21

    Mitchell Gomez

    We will make sure they all live near Yucca Mountain and then that cultural narrative around glowing icats guarding dangerous places will survive Beyond language and so I think the story of Purium is an older story I think it is a psychedelic remnant of Judaism's Psychedelic history. Um.

    49:14.26

    shefaflow

    Oh.

    49:26.58

    Mitchell Gomez

    And if you haven't read the immortality key which is about how christianity likely began as a psychedelic mystery school I think I loved the book I I think the author did a great job and I don't think this was an oversight this was a matter of focus right? because it's already a pretty large dense read. But I think one of the things that would have really been good to mention. Is that Jesus was not introducing. Ah this idea of a psychedelic sacrament from outside judaism um, the galilee is one of those areas where oshara worship persisted where there were small temple cults that ah Hezekiah never controlled. And I think the broad use of a psychedelic sacrament within judaism survived in the galilee into that period. Um, and I think ah, Jesus and Mary were reintroducing ah this psychedelic sacrament that had only been wiped out a few hundred years before right? I mean I forget the exact years Hezekiah was around but it was.

    50:20.70

    shefaflow

    Um, yes, yes.

    50:21.73

    Mitchell Gomez

    But than Millennia right? It was within a a millennia of the lifetime of Jesus ah, and we see this like in the in the new testament where in Roman and jewish law a claim to be divine would be charged as blasphemy. But Jesus was not charged with blasphemy. He was charged with sorcery. Do you happen to know the coin word for like the coin Greek term for sorcery the actual charge that Jesus faced. Yeah, it's a.

    50:49.97

    shefaflow

    I Had to do a pass fail for my Ko a class. Oh yeah, a farm key of course.

    50:59.33

    Mitchell Gomez

    Phar okeia right? And so I think that purium is a psychedelic myth a psychedelic story that was rewritten. Um Chris clearly the the story is about.

    51:14.90

    shefaflow

    I have.

    51:15.95

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ancient Persia right? It's about it's after the exile I believe it's like it's quite late in in jewish history. But that's not really the relevant data point. Um because stories change in their in their cultural context all the time. Ah, and this underlying idea that as jews we are commanded. Once a year to become so dissolved within this altered state of consciousness that we no longer can tell the story which we no longer tell the difference between ah cursed is the black bad guy and blessed is the good guy to me does not feel like an alcoholic tradition. Does not feel to me like a tradition that grew out of drinking culture because most of these mystery schools used some version of an ergot wine right? and so with an ergot based wine a functionally lsd wine little less safety margin.

    52:08.90

    shefaflow

    Round.

    52:13.35

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, but not terrible. Ah becoming that altered is actually quite easy as most of us know right? if you take just a little too much of that ergot derivative getting to a place where you are no longer able to follow the plot of a story is quite easy. Whereas with alcohol. It's It's not right I mean alcohol has a sort of different vibe now do I have any way of proving this This is again a storytelling right? Do I have any way of proving this history I Think at some point we will.

    52:37.50

    shefaflow

    So that.

    52:50.98

    Mitchell Gomez

    Probably find direct evidence of psychedelic use within Ancient Israel we will dig up a certain pot. We'll run chemical analysis on the inside of that pot which is quite common now. Archeochemistry is ah a growing field that often uses some of the same tools that danaf uses for drug checking right? the the buker alpha

    52:58.60

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    53:07.17

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    53:07.67

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ftir that we use for drug checking is actually quite useful for archeochemist. Um, it's ah it's a sensitive piece of technology. It'll pick up very small amounts of things on the inside of a pot and if we follow.

    53:17.37

    shefaflow

    Well certainly Cannabinoids Cannabinoids um have been found in an altar. Um.

    53:25.11

    Mitchell Gomez

    Right? Cannabinoids ah, the fact that the burning bush is a plant with a huge amount of dmt and that Syrian Roo which has an aoi is also native to the area and spoken about as a you know, medicinal special plant. Ah, you could absolutely make an ayahuasca equivalent using only plants that grow within walking distance of the temple now that that is undeniably true like you could absolutely do that. Um, and if you burned both of them in an enclosed space. Ah the addition of Syrian Ru as an aoi would likely mean that you would not need to extract the dmt ah from the acacia in order to experience its smoked effects I'm going to close the door because I have some noise.

    54:08.00

    shefaflow

    Okay, so pausing here around the 54 minute so maybe Mitch maybe like let me ask you because I don't get to have this this conversation very often. All of this kind of root history work and these. Speculative hypotheses about you know the potential for um, ah, hallucinogenic psychedelic compounds being used in early cultures that have grown into abrahamic faiths such as ours. Why does it ultimately matter um versus saying like ah. I have a box of drugs that I know work I don't really need it to show up in my root source tradition. So you know I'm I'm seeing like a lot of energy and interest and excitement not just from you but to others and I often am ah i'm.

    54:56.79

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, yeah.

    55:03.17

    shefaflow

    I'm intrigued. But also you know that I don't need that. So can you tell me like why do you think that matters.

    55:09.30

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, yeah, so I have a twofold answer um the first is that I I guess I don't right altered states of consciousness from non-drug sources are real Um, people have spontaneous mystical experiences which I think is probably. Somehow and related to endogenous and Ndmt or five meo dmt but that's just to say that every thought feeling emotion that we have is a drug experience within our brain right? Our brains generate consciousness through a right right? right? and so we are We are the Ape that.

    55:33.84

    shefaflow

    Yeah I'm having a serotonin trip right now.

    55:46.32

    Mitchell Gomez

    You know, seize drugs you know. However, you want to phrase it ah and so the fact that non-ordinary states of consciousness are part of judaism is undeniable right? There is simply no way to read ezekiel as anything other than a non-ordinary state of consciousness. Um, there's no way to read the narrative of ah of the exodus and the wanderings through the desert as anything other than a non-or very state of consciousness because that is a seven day walk right? like that it is not a 40 year experience in the desert that is a metaphorical description. Of a tremendous amount of time spent in search of a goal right? It is a description of a non-ordinary state of consciousness ah around yearning and longing for home and for. A place in which to be safe as yourself. Ah, whether those non-ordinary states of consciousness that became judaism were potentiated by outside drugs.

    56:47.45

    shefaflow

    Right.

    56:51.98

    Mitchell Gomez

    Or by inside ones right through other means I don't think is actually super important I I do think it's true like I think they were I think that drugs were a part of it. Um I think the evidence around the showbread and the acacia being so clearly delineated as an important part of.

    57:01.37

    shefaflow

    Is.

    57:11.54

    Mitchell Gomez

    The exodus the pillar of fire the burning Bush like the fact that the burning bush is the highest concentration of dmt outside of the new world I think those are unlikely to be accidents. That it's that that they just picked this random tree for no reason as being so important connecting it with burning connecting the burning with connection with hashem like that just seems really unlikely to be an accident to me. Um, that feels like a thing that is trying to preserve knowledge around the importance of that plant. And its connection to burning it and it non-ordinary states of consciousness and so yeah I think that I think it's true. Whether or not it's important. Um, but there isn't 1 small context in which I think it may be important and that is this sort of growing narrative that I think is appropriate and I think is real around. Ah. Cultural appropriation and respecting the cultural history of psychedelic using communities as we as predominantly sort of white westerners. You know I I don't actually think jews are white in the real meaning of the term but you know we are part of this white cultural milieu which involves. Exploitation of indigenous community. It involves. Ah you know financial taking from indigenous community. Um, and so the fact that there are like hundreds of indigenous tribes that have a relationship with psilocybin and now like white owned western pharmaceutical companies are trying to patent and control. It.

    58:29.14

    shefaflow

    Extraction.

    58:44.34

    Mitchell Gomez

    Does not sit well with me. There's a million psilocybin analogs by all means research those right I have no no issue at all with that. Um, there are some that are literally pro drugs I mean 4 a so dmt converts into silasin within your within your liver and so like yeah by all means. Ah. But to simply take this thing which you know most famously among the maztech is a survived tradition that dates back thousands of years before christianity and perhaps before judaism right? We might be talking about a cultural practice that predates judaism.

    59:17.34

    shefaflow

    Yeah, that's that yeah.

    59:19.66

    Mitchell Gomez

    Which is real hard to process because like we've been. We've been around for a while um and then to take that and remove it from that context and exploit it commercially I I don't love and so I think that from that perspective alone. It really makes sense to. Look really seriously at the potential psychedelic histories of our own traditions and see if those are things that we can connect with outside of the sort of exploitation and ah appropriation of indigenous psygular practices. So like I have personally never consumed Ayhuasca I've consumed phar ahuasca I've taken dmt and synthetic maois I actually used a a harmonline derivative drug that exists within medical markets. Ah. You also don't purge like the purging is primarily because of plant tannins and I don't like throwing up so like that was another sort of direct benefit to just creating a pharmaceutical preparation that was a similar drug experience. But the fact that you could walk into the hills between. Jerusalem and and Hevron you could walk on the land where abraham is buried and gather plants and cook them into a tea that would provide the same drug combination as ayahuasca. Why would we not just choose to connect with.

    01:00:52.98

    Mitchell Gomez

    That right with our indigenous homeland um has the same plants. There's very strong evidence that our ancestors engaged with those plants in a way that was designed to alter consciousness. Ah, whether or not they did clearly the non-ordinary states of consciousness. Themselves are really core to what judaism was in those days right? The whole sort of ah even after the Hezekiah reforms right? The fact that the high priest on the holiest day went into a secret place to alter his consciousness. Right? explicitly described as altering his consciousness. The veil would rend and he would speak directly to god ah right I mean the the veil would part I guess is probably a better term said rending was from when the Christian the great story but the veil would part right? He would the the veils would open and he would see god.

    01:01:38.15

    shefaflow

    A different a different story. Ah.

    01:01:47.78

    Mitchell Gomez

    Like this is so hard for me to think of as something other than a psychedelic experience Even if there were no psychedelics involved right in the same way that you know we have these ah people who have non-ordinary states of Consciousness. Naturally. Are still really helped by the growing narrative around psychedelic integration right? because even if you didn't take a psychedelic and you have this am I allowed to talk about this I am a lot to talk about this So I know somebody who I will not out by name because part of their practice is secret but they do psychedelic Integration Psychotherapy that is the. That is the thing they do publicly the thing they do secretly is help people who have been traumatized by the experience of Alien Abductions. They've experienced psychological trauma because of this repeated abductee experience that they undergo and when I asked them.

    01:02:36.77

    shefaflow

    Just just just.

    01:02:41.78

    Mitchell Gomez

    What connection they saw between those 2 spheres of work because it felt really strange to me that those were the two things that they were really passionate about and they said to me that the connection is that with both cases. It doesn't actually matter if the experience that changed you.

    01:02:46.81

    shefaflow

    Indeed.

    01:03:01.56

    Mitchell Gomez

    Is Capital R Real or not right? if you have a really scarring psychedelic experience. You know you you get tackled by the police or even just internally right? You go into this like negative spiral and you have this really dark night of the soul psychedelic experience.

    01:03:19.54

    shefaflow

    Right? multiple.

    01:03:19.88

    Mitchell Gomez

    Is it helpful when you go talk to a therapist if they're like you just took a drug.. It's fine, right? Like no of course not it's the whole reason Psychedelic Integration Therapy exists now because that's that was the narrative and it's not helpful. It doesn't help these people who've been harmed and they said that's the same case with these Ufo abductees right? It doesn't matter. If. It's capital are real or not the trauma is real. The experience is real in the sense that you experienced it. Ah right in the same way that like just because you're your. Visit to hell happened while you were like in a tent at a festival right? and you know your body was in that tent at that Festival. You didn't go to hell it doesn't matter like that it was real to you and the trauma was real to you and so whether or not this is a drug experience.

    01:04:03.94

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    01:04:10.10

    shefaflow

    So.

    01:04:11.94

    Mitchell Gomez

    We're describing in early judaism or not in that sense doesn't matter the altered states of consciousness were real and they were a real part of what we now call judaism what we now practice as judaism this idea. That you have an obligation to move through the world in ethical ways is one that you often see grow out of people's psychedelic experiences right? This deep connection to others in the world and this recognition that ah there's a famous story about bug ah about ah Babaji Ramdas's guru.

    01:04:48.93

    Mitchell Gomez

    It's actually attributed to several different people. But I I think Babaji is most likely where somebody asked him. Ah, how should we treat others and the answer was there are no others right? There are no others. There is only us there's only.

    01:04:49.26

    shefaflow

    Um.

    01:05:01.21

    shefaflow

    Um.

    01:05:07.83

    Mitchell Gomez

    This 1 thing unfolding. Ah there is only this one present moment right? There is no actual place that is the future or place that is the past. Um, it's why I fundamentally do not believe time travel will ever be possible because there is no past to go to time is inexorably linked with space. We are moving through time in this in a sense that like we have a narrative of past present and future. But in reality. The only thing that actually exists is right now and like boy have psychedelics shown me that like in just the most powerful ways.

    01:05:37.17

    shefaflow

    Circle.

    01:05:46.16

    Mitchell Gomez

    Ah, and that idea that like there is no past to go to. There is no future. There is only now also shows up in judaism our understandings of the messianic age right is part of the reason that jews broadly simply did not accept Jesus as the messiah in first century palestine.

    01:05:46.61

    shefaflow

    Okay, okay.

    01:06:05.56

    Mitchell Gomez

    Because if he had been the messiah. We would not be. We would be living in the messianic age that is what it would mean for the muhif to come is that it is a fundamental shift in the now and if that shift hasn't happened the messhif has not come and so ah, you know this is.

    01:06:17.85

    shefaflow

    And.

    01:06:24.25

    Mitchell Gomez

    Why you know some Jews certainly converted. You know most of the early christians were former Jews but I think it's part of why christianity found so much more success outside of the Jewish world than inside. Um is because of this shift that was occurring within the understanding of what it means for the mushhiak to have come.

    01:06:38.22

    shefaflow

    Are.

    01:06:42.62

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, and it worked within a a pagan context and I don't mean that as a majority of I Just mean it is a descriptor of the communities. Um, it worked within a pagan context that simply did not work within a Jewish context and not understanding. Yeah.

    01:06:51.12

    shefaflow

    So let let me bring you go sorry, go ahead I Want let you finish this? Ah well then I want to bring you to the second part of this part of the talmud. Um, first this statement about the obligation to getting drunk but then.

    01:06:57.91

    Mitchell Gomez

    No, no please I Just say that understanding feels very psychedelic to me.

    01:07:09.72

    shefaflow

    There is a story so there's the halaha. There's the actually the the law code that is given. But then there isn't Agada There's a story that follows it and the story goes as follows Raba and rabizera my 2 ah. Comrades to rabbinic comrades. They were preparing a purim feast with each other and they became intoxicated to the point that raba arose and murdered Rabbi Zera the next day. When he became sober and he realized what he had done raba asked god for mercy and revived rabizera he brought him back from death the next year raba said to rabizera let the master you let the master come and let us prepare the purim feast with each other. And bezera said to him miracles do not happen each and every hour so you know this kind of ah to me this feels like the core harm reduction text that we find maybe not only in. Ah.

    01:08:18.47

    Mitchell Gomez

    Um, yeah.

    01:08:19.30

    shefaflow

    Purum. But maybe all of judaism that we don't rely on miracles and you know what? What do you see is the relationship between the 2 parts of this passage and the p talmah first you know the way that you were describing not only the obligation to drink on purum but this kind of ah. Psychedelic ethos that is commingled with judaism if not at the heart of judaism itself and then kind of contained by this story about what happens in reality. Um, when we start to actually put this into policy and how we then have to navigate. Relationships real harm potential death and I guess the only way to bring someone back from death itself is is a supernatural revival. How do you feel about this second half of the story.

    01:09:09.84

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, so before answering those 2 things I do just want to note that that feels again like a coded message around psychedelic dissolving and reforming right? This idea that they got so altered that he died and then revived seems again to be 1 of those.

    01:09:17.96

    shefaflow

    Please.

    01:09:29.60

    Mitchell Gomez

    Coded hints around what psychedelics can do right? Yeah yeah I mean ah if you feed someone if you feed a person a super powerful psychedelic and they experience death.

    01:09:32.76

    shefaflow

    Well, he was murdered robb. Ah Ra murdered him and then and then prayed for him to come back? Yeah, ah I see I see.

    01:09:45.86

    Mitchell Gomez

    How would they frame that in within the psychedelic space. Yeah, he was he was murdered and then came back. Yeah, one of the early ah Christian communities that there's really strong evidence for psychedelic use around the phrase that they would have like over doorpost is if you die before you die, you won't die when you die.

    01:10:00.81

    shefaflow

    Yes, of course.

    01:10:05.64

    Mitchell Gomez

    Right? that this idea of like experiencing death allows you to better navigate when it happens. But yeah I think that that is a a clear message around harm reduction as Well. If you do a thing and experience significant harm because of it. Ah, you don't get to keep doing it under the excuse of ah I survived right? like I lived so it's okay, right I live So it's okay that I you know had to be intubated or I live. So it's okay that I was running around throwing bricks through windows or I mean these are all things that I've expected I've like watched happen right? I've I've. I've seen someone in a deep sort of State State of Psychedelic distress like smashing windows in a parking lot at a festival like that was ah, a real thing that I had to help navigate the person because like how do you approach this person without putting yourself in physical danger right? I mean this is a person who is experiencing something clearly very terrifying and is trying to defend themselves. So how you like navigate with that person. Ah yeah I think that as Jews we have not only an obligation to repair the world and to provide harm reduction services despite what the law may say. I Also think as individuals. Ah, we have an obligation to learn to use drugs safely if we want to use them right? You don't get to be cavalier about your own safety within Judaism Um, Ah, the cool nefe is is more than just a.

    01:11:37.58

    Mitchell Gomez

    And obligation to save other lives. It is a moral principle that life itself is worth saving and that that includes you right? like your life is also worth saving. You can also violate mitzvote to save your own life right? I need to drive to the hospital on Chavez I think I'm having a heart attack. Like you can get in that car and drive. It is totally fine to do that. It is not just saving another life. It is saving life. Ah, and so if you are a ah ah Jew who uses drugs and I tend to extrapolate jewish moral principles out to the world at at large but that's probably not super appropriate but I'll speak as ah as a jew. Ah.

    01:12:09.10

    shefaflow

    This.

    01:12:15.68

    Mitchell Gomez

    I Do think we have an obligation to be careful and conscientious and intentional about how we move through the world whether that involves drugs or not right? Ah, you don't get to not wear your seat belt and speed as a jew. That is a violation of the moral principles by which we are commanded to live um or by which our ancient communities have chosen to live if you know like me you believe these things are developed not revealed. Ah you don't get to you don't get to be selfish in that way.

    01:12:39.19

    shefaflow

    Are. Um.

    01:12:51.93

    Mitchell Gomez

    Because that is fundamentally a sort of selfish attitude I will live my life. However I want and if I die I die. Ah, that's selfish. It's selfish not just in the sense that like somebody's going to have to deal with you right? if you do die. Ah, you're creating trauma in the world if you die that way. Ah, but also because we have a larger obligation to heal the world and just like within harm reduction keeping someone alive until they want to change their drug use is the first sort of principle of harm reduction. Right? You often hear like oh get them into treatment. It's like no keeping them alive with narcan means someday they may choose to enter treatment. They're never going to make that choice if they die. So our first step is to keep people alive until they want to change ah and the first step to. Fulfilling our obligation to heal. The world is being here to heal the world right? if you engage in really risky behavior and it ends your life. You have ended your ability to. Engage within Tikon Alum you and ended your ability to heal the world around you ah and have in many ways violated that principle you have violated that commandment. Um by not staying around until you couldn't anymore. Ah, and you know.

    01:14:16.70

    Mitchell Gomez

    It's a painful subject like I've had many many friends who fast away from drugs I have friends who've volitionally ended their own lives I and I don't think either 1 of those are mine to judge right? How those people made those choices. Ah speaking for myself. This is an obligation I believe I have right is to be careful enough to be conscientious enough around how I engage with substances how I engage with the world. Ah that I can continue to be in the world and I can continue to do my best to heal the world. Ah, to repair the world to leave the world better than I entered it. Ah, because yeah, you know like we started off this conversation saying ah faults and prayers is a sin within judaism we. Don't get to say like ah ah it's it's okay, how shame we'll fix it like that's. That's not how it works. Ah, he fixed it. You know again within this cultural narrative the way in which god fixed the world was by giving it to us to steward that was the that was the moment where god fixed the world. Is he gave it to humanity and now it's ours with all that that entails. Ah and you know I see a lot of ways in which you know at this moment in time it feels strange not to talk about how.

    01:15:49.90

    Mitchell Gomez

    Little I'm seeing around tik ko along within my israeli friends right? This idea that we have ah or the colon nefesh right? This idea that we have an obligation to protect life. An obligation to heal the world. And I've lost a lot of israeli friends by reminding them that that obligation does not exist only when politically easy that is an obligation that exists at all times and I I do fundamentally believe that people have a right to defend their lives from aggression. I do not believe that that right extends to causing harm to those who are not trying to harm you and that the ways in which I mean I wanted to make a t-shirt that said I hated Bb before it was cool because it's so true, but the ways in which I'm seeing Lee could ah.

    01:16:34.49

    shefaflow

    Ah I think most Israelis would probably buy that you have a big market. Yeah.

    01:16:38.67

    Mitchell Gomez

    but hey but I still shoot out of Israel I mean if if it yeah and it's most yeah look I you know look I marched against the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan like what did that? do right? like it happened. Um I marched in Israel at Rabin Memorial rallies

    01:16:54.90

    Mitchell Gomez

    With hundreds of thousands of other of ah of israelis right? I mean some of these rallies in the early two thousand s were huge number I mean a substantial percentage of the population was at some of these these rab memorial rallies I I am not extrapolating this out to israelis at large but. What I am saying is that these obligations if they don't exist when they're hard. They don't exist and that applies to ah things like geopolitical defense as much as it applies to drugs that we have an individual problematic relationship with There are I have absolutely no attraction to opiates I have never craved Numbness the times I've tried opiates I've found them to be boring and when I I stopp taking them. You know like I add a knee injury and a foot injury and a dog. But yeah I've had several large injuries in my life where I was prescribed opiates. And when I reached the end of my script I stopped and I never had ah a single craving for additional opiates. Ah stimulants I have to be careful around my relationship with and it would be in many ways, easy to not be careful with that relationship right? like just burn the candles at both end I got a lot to do. Like to do list is always growing like I love the way they make my brain twitch. Um, it would be very very easy to be cavalier with that relationship. Ah, and so that's where that obligation right? But cool neish comes not from when it's easy. But from when it's hard. Ah.

    01:18:27.28

    Mitchell Gomez

    And so yeah, our obligation to save life starts with us because you're not saving any other lives if. You're not here and so pco neish begins as the individual and then spreads from the individual to society as a whole. Ah. Starting with our own community simply because I believe it's where we are most effective at engaging within these principles right? But my belief in tikun alum does not stop at the borders of my nation. It doesn't stop at the end of my family first right? My takunah alum does not stop at my family. It does not stop at my community. It does not stop at the borders of my nation. It does not stop at my species right? It is a top to bottom obligation to minimize harm. It is a. Call for harm reduction in the grandest sense I all the way down to I forget which rush it's from but this this obligation that like if you must kill an animal you have to do so as painlessly as possible, right? All of the wall around kashwood like.

    01:19:35.89

    shefaflow

    Shrita. Yeah.

    01:19:39.31

    Mitchell Gomez

    Thank you, thank you? Ah right? Literally the most painless way in which to take an animal's life is the way in which we are commanded to take their life. Ah, which if you think about the ancient world is really astonishing right? and that is really astonishing that judaism. Was thinking about minimizing harm to animals needed to survive thirty five hundred years ago like that is a narrative that still barely exists within the world and yet it was a core part. You cannot eat this animal. If it was killed in a way which caused it needless pain you are forbidden from consuming it if it was made to suffer before it died to me that makes clear that these obligations don't end at. Any arbitrary division. There is no point at which we get to draw a line and say on this side of the line those living creatures are worthy of life and worthy of ah our efforts to reduce our harms to them and on the other side of that line. Those creatures are not worthy of that. It doesn't even end at living beings I mean to me, it's an obligation to literally healed the world right? If you're going to extract resources from the world. We are required to do so in a way that is as we minimize the harms of that behavior. It's not a prohibition on taking an animal's life.

    01:21:14.14

    Mitchell Gomez

    It's not a prohibition on extracting resources. It's not a prohibition on existing within the world. It is a principle that because our mere existence impacts the world we have to shape our existence in a way. That our benefit to the world outweighs the harm we have caused because we cannot.. It's not harm elimination like harm elimination is not a term that exists right? It's it's harm Reduction. We are required to reduce the harms that we cause top to bottom. Not just around drug use not just around sexual practices not just around protecting our hearing in everything we do from how we eat to how we navigate relationship to how we navigate political life to how we navigate resource extraction. How we navigate our own decisions our own minds. Our own bodies. We must as Jews Do everything we can in all of those spheres to maximize benefit and reduce harm and that's really beautiful like that's a really beautiful way of thinking about. Our place within the world. Our place within reality ah is that we don't choose to be here. But once here we can choose to make sure that we're a net gain to this thing.

    01:22:44.38

    Mitchell Gomez

    This ever present now that exists.

    01:22:46.53

    shefaflow

    Well in the voice of in somehow the voice of um maimonides mosha Ben Maimmon who opened up the guide to the perplexed in a most similar way right? The entire effort of the law. Is to maintain and preserve the life of the individual and the community I want to thank you? Ah Mitchell Gomez Mosha Aharon for your life and actually absolutely brotherly love within you? um.

    01:23:20.56

    Mitchell Gomez

    My parents had high hopes. Um.

    01:23:25.38

    shefaflow

    Um, thank you for your service to yourself to your communities. Your spheres of of impact and for this blessed world This gift to preserve.

    01:23:40.29

    Mitchell Gomez

    Yeah, thank you for having me on was always really great talking with you I feel like we never get quite as much time as I wish we had so maybe someday. Well ah if I ever feel comfortable going back to Israel I'm not sure if it's going to happen but I very much miss it and very much someday would like to stand in front of the Kotel again.

    01:23:54.59

    shefaflow

    Hopefully shoulder to shoulder Bezra hasham.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Dr. Alan Brill

Once a year, Jews are invited to expand their consciousness with the aid of a sacred psychoactive substance to dissolve the binary boundaries between human existence. What other special states of consciousness exist within the Jewish mystical tradition? How are they integrated into daily life? Are they congruous in any way with psychedelic experiences? Rabbi Zac explored these questions and more with Dr. Alan Brill, scholar of Jewish theology and spirituality.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

  • Alan Brill is the Cooperman/Ross Endowed Chair in the Jewish-Christian Studies Graduate Program in the Department of Religion at Seton Hall University. He specializes in interfaith theology, mysticism, and comparative theology. Brill is the author of several books including Judaism and Other Relgions; Judaism and World Religions; and Rabbi on the Ganges: A Jewish-Hindu Encounter based on his time as a Fulbright Senior Scholar Award at Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, India. He is currently working on a book on a Jewish view of religious diversity and was a keynote speaker at the recent R20 summit in Bali

    Brill has taught Kabbalistic meditation on and off for 30 years in many settings. He has presented on Jewish meditation in Indian centers including the Tantra Institute in New Delhi, in Varanasi, and in Haridwar. He has spoken to experts in these locations about similarities and differences between the practices. Eventually, these explorations will form a book on Jewish visualization meditations.

  • 00:02.86

    shefaflow

    What was your first encounter with psychedelic anything were you a child teenager. How did it act your life.

    00:09.16

    Alan Brill

    Oh probably teenager at some point long time ago.

    00:16.37

    shefaflow

    Meaning like it was around and you knew it was happening.

    00:18.59

    Alan Brill

    It was ah it was it was around and it's you know the tail end of the first incarnation of it. Um, in which people 1520 years my senior or anybody who was just entering the fields of anything jewish were really into it.

    00:38.44

    Alan Brill

    At least at some point in their life.

    00:41.30

    shefaflow

    And what what did it mean to be into it like it. Um, it was exciting. It was it was making people feel nervous or unsafe. Can you give us a sense of that moment.

    00:56.89

    Alan Brill

    Um, can I give you a sense? No I guess it was something you know a lot of the big names who went into jewish mysticism and elsewhere or people who became rabbis and whatever it was part of their. 1960 SAnd seventy s experience I am 15 years younger so in some way they were my junior teachers but beyond that I don't really remember much.

    01:26.58

    shefaflow

    Um, well as many people know or people are getting to know just to from meeting you through this podcast that you are a scholar of jewish theology and mysticism i. First came to know your work through your fantastic blog which we'll be linking to um, but for people who are just entering into this conversation psychedeically or Jewishly there is a lot of interest in getting really quick into jewish mysticism.

    01:57.51

    Alan Brill

    Right.

    01:59.71

    shefaflow

    And people don't always know the ah the onramp for that. So maybe could you talk about what is mysticism generally and ah what is Jewish Mysticism specifically.

    02:06.39

    Alan Brill

    And written. So I'm I'm going to backtrack because you asked me what do I remember as if there was this outside the system but in the end I made me more specific now that I think about what you're really asking my I wound up doing my. Dissertation and mysticism at fordham university my adviser you were cousins was part of the good Friday experiments all the people as a participant he was one of those newly people who renounced being a priest.

    02:28.65

    shefaflow

    Right.

    02:36.90

    shefaflow

    Um, as a participant aha.

    02:45.13

    Alan Brill

    And in 62 and then wound up getting into this sort of stuff and he then went off to an indian reservation to experience a native american spirituality and he had a program at Fordham in mysticism. And um, so therefore a lot of the catholic professors protestant members were in some way part of the good Friday or some other connection to punk's research know that.

    03:17.90

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    03:21.35

    Alan Brill

    From the research of masters in Houston on the 4 levels of psychic experience and standnis off Gloff. They came to visit our program we did mysticism with you know Gene Houston showing up in the class to disrupt it.

    03:26.33

    shefaflow

    Have 5

    03:35.50

    shefaflow

    Wow.

    03:37.36

    Alan Brill

    The program. The program took us through field trips to um, see the young center so we understand how to interpret Archetypes is a pre-we age you actually have to go to a center and they had aisles. What does this archtype mean.

    03:55.70

    shefaflow

    Wow.

    03:56.89

    Alan Brill

    Um, and the classics of western spirituality were being edited out of fordham meaning you were cousins was the editor and that was that turn to mysticism post good Friday experience post the changes of the sixty s and 70 s.

    04:13.70

    shefaflow

    Ever.

    04:15.34

    Alan Brill

    And that's really you know to give you some grounding before we get to the specifics that was my graduate program. So unlike yeah, so unlike most.

    04:19.69

    shefaflow

    Yes, okay you were You're in you were in the womb of it all.

    04:31.14

    Alan Brill

    Jewish Graduate programs that regardless of but how the participants got there at that point turned incredibly historic and philological our program cousins believe that mysticism was about the psychological journey through stages. About the minds ascent into mystic structures. It's about the Archetypes Um, and yes it was historic and critical but it was not the program was a very different sort of program and it attracted.

    05:06.99

    Alan Brill

    Different sorts of people.

    05:10.20

    shefaflow

    So what? what? Then after your encounter in that time which feels like deeply experiential. You're in contact with the people who are. Not only kind of at the forefront of the study of mysticism comparative mysticism but also of Psychedelic Psychotherapy Um, now in your in your teaching and ah in your in your research and writing what what would you say then is.

    05:35.27

    Alan Brill

    And.

    05:42.90

    shefaflow

    Ah, if there is everything that you learned about mysticism in your program and since then um, how does it actually relate to entheogenic drugs in any way.

    05:52.63

    Alan Brill

    So at that point I mean um, you know in some way we're reproducing old debates. This should have been settled forty years ago ok so

    06:02.42

    shefaflow

    Um, ah, settle it for us now.

    06:08.40

    Alan Brill

    You know, know all the people whether punk masters. Um I don't know you you know list. The people who did experiments who did it from a psychological from a so um from a healing from a social work from a mystical from history all came out and. Showed that there's an overlap of experience. The would the dissenting voice was a scholar at Oxford by the name of zehner who put out I think 4 or 5 books saying that there was no overlap between mysticism. And the use of drugs but you look at the books today and they don't really say that because there used to be this concept called mysticism in which mysticism meant Uneo Mystica and it's the same for all people in all cultures and therefore whether you are taking nitrous oxide or you have an great great spiritual experience of a sunset or you meditate and you reach a state or you're a great saint or a rioche. It's all the same.

    07:22.46

    shefaflow

    Has.

    07:24.98

    Alan Brill

    So Zaner spent several books arguing that whatever you're experiencing with the drugs is not the same as John of the cross. It's not the same as ah, shankarra. But on the but the point is. So everyone said good. So that's not what the issue is the fact that you take a eight week course in Buddhist meditation and you get some sort of um mindfulness and oneness experience or zen that that time zen was in you have a sense of. Some sort of sataura from a from a summer program in zen that doesn't make you into the master. You don't become the ah you don't become the leader by doing that. But at that point there was a real confusion. There was a book also put out by Stace who argued philosophically that all mysticism is the same and it was. It was pretty much nonsense because anybody who was doing psychology in the sixty s seventy s into the 80 s showed there are dozens of experiences on many many different levels.

    08:25.65

    shefaflow

    I have.

    08:40.90

    Alan Brill

    Even in the end Zena was saying that himself. But if you take a premise that all mysticism in the same then drugs have got to be very different. But once you now assume there are many levels of experience then that's great. It will open you up. You'll definitely experience something you can compare it to it with summertime meditation class. You can take ah compare it to alcohol you can compare it to many things and proceed with it.

    09:12.84

    shefaflow

    But so according to you now that the subjective experience of a either short-lived ah whether it's spontaneous or something that is cultivated over Time. Um. Ability to achieve expanded consciousness is not ah, materially similar to a drug induced a psychoactive induced experience of expanded consciousness.

    09:43.84

    Alan Brill

    No I'm not saying it's different materially mean now you can do whether you want to do brain away now you can do ah you know Mris and cat scans. You can show quite a bit of overlap but that doesn't make you and that doesn't mean you know how how far you are.

    09:59.39

    shefaflow

    Um, ah so about so something about experience and authority.

    10:06.60

    Alan Brill

    It's not authority. It's also how you view I mean the the one that I usually use in class to explain it is they did row Sharks tests the you could have an experience and you're going to see something in the row Sharks test.

    10:10.10

    shefaflow

    This is with her.

    10:21.80

    Alan Brill

    No ignore everyone else when you start getting that sense of oneness of being that spirituality oneness. You start seeing the same row shas test as jazz musicians and other creative Beings. You've reached a certain stage and the drugs got you there but like as groff said you could do this through Breathwork. You could do this through lots of means and then we see the next levels. We now see the roserus test going Overly simple. That you've blocked everything out and it's less creative and fun. But you've now in some way put on much more blinders to the rest of the world.

    11:11.91

    shefaflow

    So coming back to maybe the contemporary Psychedelic Renaissance if you will um it seems to me that a good amount of the frameworks that researchers often use with regards to mystical experience either. The mystical experience questionnaire or the hood scale or assertions about how mystical experiences can be occasioned by Particular. Um. But particular psychoactive materials and here are the all of the qualities that make up a mystical experience. Does it does that mean that they're maybe using um, outdated information. They're using Outdated frameworks.

    11:58.60

    Alan Brill

    So I think a lot of people are not speaking to each other you know, First of all, you know the ayahuasca experiences and the new books coming out all you know, go into shamanic language which is not the same as mystical language.

    11:59.46

    shefaflow

    Um, that have kind of maybe been updated but not applied.

    12:17.97

    Alan Brill

    I Don't think you know I don't think whether the shaman the ayahuasca and a number of things a number of things that bring involuntary visions are the same as ah, the remark.

    12:26.15

    shefaflow

    Um.

    12:36.18

    Alan Brill

    Mosha corvero telling you he's going up to the clouds of the unfeeling k or to put in other terms of some scholars in California Walsh and company who you know actually you know shown, you could just differentiate. You know by blood pressure rate. Voluntary involuntary and if you want you can speak completely clinical, but the very fact that we now have shamanic categories and mystical categories and oneness categories and creative categories. You know I your. Program was run by um William Richards right okay bill so Bill in his book. You know point blank is going to say there are people who have eyesome? Yeah Thank you you know very clear. There are people having experiences of wholeness and oneness.

    13:12.50

    shefaflow

    Yeah Bell yeah.

    13:29.56

    Alan Brill

    Then experiences of um, opening the door positive mood and doors then separate from doors of perception separate then disillusion of the self separate than Archetypal visions. The mystical was a funny.

    13:32.34

    shefaflow

    Positive mood.

    13:48.44

    Alan Brill

    Protestant category created by William James once upon a time with incredibly you know, very very protestant alone to the alone terms that make no sense. I mean I was teaching I mean onces were on this already I was teaching in India to a class of hindu and buddhist ah students most of the but buddhist students had spent years in the monastery meditating.

    14:05.12

    shefaflow

    Please.

    14:20.65

    Alan Brill

    And I taught them William James and they taught me even stronger how William James makes no sense. First of all, you're not not alone to the alone you need a guru. You need a path. You need someone who's not showing you what to do.

    14:26.82

    shefaflow

    For.

    14:39.40

    Alan Brill

    You need training. It's like any athletics. Um it needs the assesses the training of an athlete to in order to do it. That's just what in a buddhist thats from their buddhist monastery point of view and these were you know thai buddhists. This is not people who. Just took a week these were you know people who were going now for a graduate degree in religion because they're going to be leaders and so they're taking me and they're telling me how wrong James says in everything he's saying so it's coming out of that. The word mysticism is really. Coming from the world of James. It has Quaker it has liberal protestant roots. It's not when I even teach jewish mysticism 1 of the first texts I'll do after doing James, let's define. Our terms is I then do Julian of Norwich. In which you're now going to get this incredibly painful bloody embodied vision that is none in any way like James and then I'll do something like depending on the year you know the best descent into heaven where he speaks to all the heavenly. Also nothing to do with James. Um, and there's no reason to use that same word and we trip on that word when you ask me? what does it have to do with mysticism I have no idea what you're talking about.

    16:13.54

    Alan Brill

    Murmur going back to statesce wrote this book and it was very influential on zener and others is that it's all the same I have taught hindus and buddhists I've taught it in India I've lectured kabbalah in the tantra centers in India I have taught hindus in.

    16:16.47

    shefaflow

    Yeah, right.

    16:31.58

    Alan Brill

    Hindus and muslims in Indonesia you know this is not just my sitting back. This is really in interchange with them and we now have a huge variety of visions dreams disillusion of the self feelings of well-being.

    16:35.38

    shefaflow

    Yes, of course.

    16:50.15

    Alan Brill

    Ah, Maggi them visualization lights this huge realm of experiences which used to be but used to be called altered states of consciousness the book by Charles Tart and Daniel Goldman somehow fell out of fashion. But they got it much more right much more correct you know because they were even they were even just sitting back as jews in new england post the you know post the psychedelic era saying look are options of.

    17:12.84

    shefaflow

    So.

    17:25.97

    Alan Brill

    Zen and our option ah of options of the pasta and our options of gery f and going to dance with the suvis are not all the same. There's a variety of altered states of consciousness and therefore does it overlap with drugs a hundred percent

    17:44.52

    shefaflow

    So let's imagine that either you were in the position or that there are psychedelic researchers who are listening right now and what you've shared is um. About the multiplicity of altered states or expanded states of consciousness and not narrowing down to ah staces or William James's ah, very limited categories of these experiences. First of all, what would you call it would you want to ditch the word mysticism and. How would you? How would you maybe start to measure people's experiences without some universal categories. Is it possible.

    18:30.66

    Alan Brill

    Um, so I think everybody would measure in their own terms meaning the the you know Neurobiologist does 1 way the psychologist another way. Um, the. Biopsychologist another way the historian of mysticism another way the anthropologist but then they all have to then speak to each other you know and then you're bringing back now that it's being used and in medical things bring all the data together I notch I mean in some way tart and um. Goldman did a better job of bringing together everything then than anybody now. Um so the question is I do think it should be measured. It's not my field to measure it in the scientific ways. It is it is my way to be teaching mysticism.

    19:19.79

    shefaflow

    Of course.

    19:26.21

    Alan Brill

    And comparative mysticism around the world I taught comparative mysticism and we still use that word in Indonesia Once again almost nothing of the James's category played any role in the classroom. Because everybody in Indonesia believes in some sort of sufi animism to reality some sort of everything is infused with the divine they believe in our oneness of reality they believed in sufi saints and let's go up at midnight to pray there.

    19:50.61

    shefaflow

    So.

    20:01.35

    Alan Brill

    And none of that really fits into this classic word. You know I then you know in Bali or very naci I've I've experienced all these different senses and I'm not going to look to put it all into 1 category. As much as a variety because even bill in his book says look I'm going to you know I'm going to use the word spirituality rather than mysticism or religious because that's what people use now. But we gett all agree that you know there's more than 1 word that could be used. There's a variety of experiences here's my data look at all the stuff I produced I'll tell you that from being in the field speaking to people around the world. There's lots of experiences. We used to distinguish between the mystical and the shamanic for example, um.

    20:55.12

    shefaflow

    The first.

    20:59.23

    Alan Brill

    Which in some way if you want to put it. Ah you know in some way it's you know now will it include the meditative or the contemplative as a third category and so I'm not going to see it as all one and I do think some experiences could have qualities of more than one.

    21:18.79

    shefaflow

    So Maybe we can ah shift our focus a little bit. You've already opened up the the possibility or maybe the reality of um, the varieties of experience inner experience. But. Maybe dropping down to ah the major states of Consciousness. Of course there's a myriad but some major states of consciousness that we find in Jewish Sacred Literature mystical or otherwise um, that Maybe. Ah, Jewish Psychedelic Explorer um would want to familiarize themselves with from the literature and then maybe to understand their direct experience in those terms if they so choose.

    22:07.60

    Alan Brill

    So that's a you know it's a good question. Um, you know the quickest answer I would give let's say or bat track if we think about Baba Ram Dass around us he didn't know what he was doing. He found the Tibetanbook of the dead with Tim Leary and company. They completely misread it. They did not know what to make of it. Yeah, they miss they misread it. They had no idea that it's a magical text to really be read over the dead body in a funeral. It wasn't you know.

    22:31.23

    shefaflow

    There It is right there.

    22:43.18

    Alan Brill

    But it was the only source they're getting of all of of archetypal imagery and disillusion of the self There's a lot I could say on that on one hand if you wanted a quick answer for people who are not even going to listen to the end of this, you know I would start and take. For the archetypal I would take Howard Schwartz's Tree of Souls here's a rather you know midrash-ic Kabalistic, here are the all the archetypes of of demons trees of life dragons and all sorts of things from visions. And read Aryeh Kaplan’s meditation in the Kabbalah which gives an overview of more than ah, more than two dozen different types of experience that was written in a conjunction with psychologists because he gathered a group post the first psychedelic era in which all the psychologists you know had on some level some experience. They were old. They were already a little older at that point and that's who he thought he was going to understand mysticism with. Not the historians the philologists but with the psychologists and therefore that's one of the few books meditation the kabbalah that presents Kabbalah from a psychological experiential point of view but things that one should know about.

    24:13.90

    Alan Brill

    You should know about jewish meditation techniques cover notes. Also you should know about a sense of light shaha kavana kubali me gen name. You should know about abu la is the automation techniques. You should know hasidic sense of. Higher and lower unities and sense of mindfulness. You know it's how about harry vo is someone should have made that into a mindfulness text years ago. Um you know all of all of it plays a role. You need them. You need to know the meditation the contemplation. The deautoion. The sense of well-being and text you need to know my a myth and symbol jewish views of leviathan demons angels from interpret experiences the jewish book of the dead. My very ahvo by aaron berechia has never been translated or even partially translated because here it's talking about the dissolution of the self and into death and then you come to lower and higher states of afterlife and. And the question is not empirically how do they know? are they just making this up. That's not the issue but it's giving you this rich jewish language of the jewish book of the dead like most cultures have around the world in which that is the language and the imagery and the symbols that are rather archetypal.

    25:44.90

    Alan Brill

    For Jews Um, you know.

    25:46.72

    shefaflow

    Can we pause on just that that one particular work so you know something that I see often in psychedelic works psychedelic text psychedelic media is the ascendance of. Achieving ego death right? that that's the one of the best possible outcomes of 1 ne's psychedelic engagement is for the ego to die. Would you say that that the way that is spoken about now that is similar to the sense in this. Text that you're describing or is it something completely different.

    26:23.96

    Alan Brill

    So This text is all of the above its ego death and its Archetypal visions of you know, otherworldly beings and it's opening doors to new perceptions of revelation. It's a mixture of many different things.

    26:43.80

    shefaflow

    Well maybe we can follow up on on this particular text another time.

    26:47.10

    Alan Brill

    But you mean it' the 1 thing is you keep saying like this is the ideal you know, but at the same times Bill Richards himself gives you you know, but in the end there's this huge number of things and I'm just going to put in it I forgot 4 or 5 chapters of different types of things that people. Do get in his research.

    27:06.41

    shefaflow

    Absolutely I I mean I am not of the opinion that the ego death is the the height of of any particular experience but just one of the particular experiences that a person could encounter and if they do then how are they prepared for.

    27:21.12

    Alan Brill

    Yeah, right? So so there are hasidic next that involved Boat Hitpa stood a gosh Meot being divestment of corporeality the a assess the ascetic moving Beyond the body and into the.

    27:26.36

    shefaflow

    Such a thing. Um, yeah.

    27:40.62

    Alan Brill

    Ego death in which there is no in which you turn the human yaish into an iron into a nothing and it's there and you know in some way we should have called this out forty years ago and you know created. Ah, practices and we should have created Jewish Ashrams meaning the pasta and the and mindfulness is not really buddhism I've met buddhists around the world real buddhists. Are you know, keep ah ah, keep holidays or this actually a monastery that just started in New Jersey they only eat they don't eat after midday they are celibate. They don't have possessions. They don't use social media they are looking for a good rebirth. It's not psychological but they want a good rebirth and they want their followers to support them and bring them food. Now through online you make contributions ah to what they need and you're going to earn merit that way. That's the traditional theravada system. Whatever then became our modern forms of Buddhism. In Burma and Thailand and elsewhere you know first simplified it to meditation and then tikna han even then it went beyond vi pasta and basically said mindfulness. There are so many mindful techniques even just in a simple text.

    29:13.80

    Alan Brill

    Like the savahari vach was called the testament of the ba shemov certain things have always keep god in mind keep the letters in mind just things that you would be mindful and we should have created something like that long ago. It's not about everyone returning because there's something about jews doing a switch and bait. We'll teach you this for eight weeks and then we want to then completely bring you into the system that buddhists never did that they never said ok now we're going to make you into a buddhist. We're just going to teach you more and more techniques. The overwhelming majority of people don't get beyond the first level the mindfulness or the basic watching your breath I mean the overwhelming majority. Not to say that people don't go on and. It would it would have been. We would have now you know here's the jewish meditation technique that everybody would have known or variety of techniques and it would have it would have been a contribution.

    30:16.15

    shefaflow

    Well hopefully we're on the way and in some way but I want to go back to what you were saying about the the techniques the the mindful techniques the daily practice you've described just this this ah rich.

    30:33.73

    Alan Brill

    For.

    30:33.99

    shefaflow

    Treasure house of of all of these states of consciousness that we find throughout jewish sacred literature. But I'm wondering if and we had ah we had an exchange about this maybe a year ago if there is something akin to what we. Call integration now. Psychedelic integration. Whatever we have encountered in these states of consciousness then we are trying to find ways of bringing them back grounding anchoring what we have encountered what we have seen the insight that we have gained the noetic quality of knowledge. Um, are are there ah are there techniques akin a like integration that we find in these traditions as well or are is there something else happening after someone has had this profound expansive ah experience.

    31:22.95

    Alan Brill

    Um.

    31:25.12

    Alan Brill

    I Don't think there's any spiritual tradition. That's not about integration. That's really being on the path. You know there's an old mystical metaphor of.

    31:30.38

    shefaflow

    So.

    31:39.39

    Alan Brill

    You know you can't just collect pearls and put them in the drawer unless you string them into a piece of jewelry. You don't have a piece of jewelry. Also you know you need the string of pearls not individual pearls in the draw. So all paths are about integration. Development you have to take experiences and put them onto a path of which there are different paths because different paths will then emphasize different elements even if biologically socially and linguistically. We will have some of the same experiences but you will certainly understand it differently understand I've taught a class of mixed buddhists and hindus in India I've taught a class of mixed muslims and hindus in in Indonesia you know.

    32:26.40

    shefaflow

    Must.

    32:36.71

    Alan Brill

    And you know you watch this in front of you and people emphasize different qualities within experiences a the posum path is very different than a than a ah tantric ka of Kashmir Shivis path not that they're unrelated but there'll be an overlap the path of the remark or is the remark and what cap calls early schools is going to be different than the ira in chain vitalah is different than Abu laa. Not that there's not an overlap meaning Abu Laa will clearly think the highest levels are things like seeing a projected double. Yeah right? Oh Scott rights and which occurs quite common.

    33:25.60

    shefaflow

    Yeah, autoscopy yeah.

    33:33.80

    Alan Brill

    It's quite common if you're doing mystical techniques. Um altered states of kind but it doesn't play any role in many other you know it doesn't play a role in others for others. It's about reaching some sort of state of Oneness Beyond categories.

    33:53.42

    Alan Brill

    And that's not the the abellaa category they're related. They're even they're even textually created Coro red Abulaa then they're there. They're all this overlaps here. But that's not the same that they're all the same integration path. And that's why my class in India laughed at William James without a guru What are you talking about? So if you want to have specifics for example ri kammi kaman shapira the piecesetsna is very in right now.

    34:26.69

    shefaflow

    Yeah, yeah.

    34:29.21

    Alan Brill

    Is that if you don't have a clear path of spiritual Growing. You're not spiritual growing and he gives lots of metaphors because he was teaching Youth. You know about the need for roads or tracks. Um that unless you're getting from point a and nowhere you're going. You're not going anywhere. You could have lots of experiences and the piece sets that could take you there meaning he can you know do something and say we're now going to do this. We're now going to do this practice or this practice or this practice and some of them are actually being taught the you know the quieting technique or some of the others. That the pier sets and door. But unless you the peer sets to himself said you need to integrate it um into a path and we don't really do that now. Whether in you know, various Jewish programs. It doesn't really play a role.. There's no real even sense that there are paths um now.

    35:32.19

    shefaflow

    Well so then let me ask you so there I have been in contact with so many different kinds of jewish psychedelic explorers, various ages affiliations denominations. Um. Different levels of jewish commitment understandings of their own identity and often whether someone someone is from or someone has had no formal jewish education and is ah underserved by the jewish institutional community. Um. There is a strong urgency after a psychedelic experience after you know, ah a vision of divinity or encountering the oneness of reality um encountering 1 ne's death. They want to know what to do with that. With some urgency but the way that our jewish spiritual infrastructure exists currently in North America at least for liberal and secular minded jews there is no.

    36:35.73

    Alan Brill

    Is.

    36:41.36

    shefaflow

    On ramp to these practices or to teachers that will accept them regardless of their halacha commitment. So I'm trying to diagnose the problem and I'm trying to maybe wonder with you? What would be something that you would suggest for these folks just to get those. Ah, exposed roots into the ground.

    37:01.33

    Alan Brill

    Well I think the problem's much worse than you say because once again when we look at the buddhist categories. They completely don't even give you They don't even really are then a goal is not even to get you into the institutional buddhism and you know the most important how to keep festivals.

    37:04.63

    shefaflow

    Um, okay, ah.

    37:21.10

    Alan Brill

    And how to make daily offerings and you know, almost anyone who goes off to learn that say buddhism really has no even understanding. You know that there has to be ah the Buddha has to be on a platform that's to be a hollow underneath. You have to keep changing the water in front of it. If. There's a crack in a statue then it's it's not an invalid statue. You know here we have people who meditate and mix freely hindu buddhist symbols without any realize that they're real hallahot of these religions and real prayer times and offering times and festivals. You know, part of the attraction of buddhist modernism is they they really created something that could be attracted to people who don't want to take on the traditional thai burmese chinese japanese korean lives.

    38:04.37

    shefaflow

    Are.

    38:14.58

    shefaflow

    This.

    38:17.87

    Alan Brill

    We know like I say we should have done that for judaism we should have had some institution where you could say here is some sort of you know here are the various you know paths here is the sort of sufi duty of the heart path. Here is the you know a zekri safe for hi de path here's a mosar path here is a um habotan mystical path in which you could actually go to teachers who will continue you on the mystical path. we we lost we lost an opportunity even now I don't really see anyone doing it. We create unfortunately, people really just want 10 to one a workshop. You know here's eight weeks or whatever they want or a week no one really wants now a teacher that's now you're going to. Listen to and really take you on the journey like all the other traditions. Um, you know I know my catholic colleagues all have retreat centers not all of them are particularly doing well because people don't want to go to retreat centers. But in the retreat centers is where catholics used to do either the ignatian path or the benedictine path and you would do it as part of your upbringing you would do it. You know instead of a jews will do a gap year or studying somewhere catholics used to go to this as part of their formation.

    39:51.76

    Alan Brill

    Regardless of whether they then became a doctor lawyer requirement or whatever they became. We really don't have it and I think that if we're talking out loud to each other I can't emphasize enough the need for it. Not as some sort of just hears a.

    40:00.65

    shefaflow

    This.

    40:09.46

    Alan Brill

    Spectrum of people on a panel telling you about paths that a lee mood or a conference but a place where you actually go in and actually you know do it for a you know ten month commitment

    40:24.35

    shefaflow

    Yeah, yeah I often. Ah I use the language or the imagery of the difference between the menu and the meal that we are often being served the menu and mistaking it for the meal itself. Um, So how do we actually create. Ah the the opportunities. How do we gather the resources. How do we commit to ah actually teaching these things with teachers who who know what they're talking about and are ready to ah. Bring on lots of different types of students. Um, we're obviously not there yet. But I do feel that the urgency that psychedelic explorers often feel could be enough to ah motivate such a movement. So I Guess we'll see.

    41:17.40

    Alan Brill

    So I think I think in the Zoom age. It's much easier now to organize something like that and you can create some sort of um you know program. Um.

    41:20.30

    shefaflow

    Yeah.

    41:31.77

    Alan Brill

    There were many people who started doing that in the early two thousand s I don't know if any of those programs are still active. There are a number of individuals who were still teaching privately meditation and people will take it for jewish meditation and for eight weeks but a real program. Of you know people get very distracted into other things. Um, you know I'm not going to mention all the names of people who had little programs of various sorts. Well twenty years ago

    42:07.26

    Alan Brill

    But it really be someone who thinks that this is important right now and to provide translations. Um, just so people can then you know read the literature so they know even a sense of being brought into it of where to go.

    42:27.95

    shefaflow

    Well I want to ah again, maybe drill down a little bit deeper and more specific so we've covered major expressions of of jewish mystical or or spiritual states. What could be considered an integration path where people are right now with regard to the desire to be on a path and the the lack of options at least for this early generation. Um, but. We do have in our tradition. We do have an occasion once a year to shift consciousness using a psychoactive substance for the express purpose at least 1 express purpose of dissolving boundaries between. So particular ah types of binaries right? and this holiday is purum or ahotashtove by the way it's ah it's a dar now. Um and the the drinking of wine at least as it's described in the gomara in.

    43:29.78

    Alan Brill

    The next type.

    43:42.38

    shefaflow

    In tani is for the purpose of coming to aaloyada consciousness until one does not know consciousness. Um, could you talk a little bit about what is the meaning and purpose of this particular. Ah. Opportunity of shifting consciousness either in mystical literature or otherwise because it seems like an excellent, um, an excellent ah model for how we could think about shifting consciousness with psychoactive substances. The rest of the year

    44:16.25

    Alan Brill

    You? Yeah so I'm going to give you a start in the middle broad and then I'm going to get down to jewish. Hes um so the the fact is medieval literature understood. There's a commonality between alcohol hasshish music dance. Ecstatic joy all of them play a role and in in literature it was called the problem of Selma that you're hearing from outside it's in Al Ghazali which was translated into Hebrew Jews knew this issue. Of what? what What's the status of Selma. So we're reinventing the wheel the butievals all understood that alcohol and drugs can bring you to god but they understood it was a stage on the way. Um.

    45:09.64

    Alan Brill

    The then also to frame it before we go further the mitler redner the son of the aldoor rebi of shabad wrote a book called track on ecstasy curric at poll and it actually got translated by Louis Jacobs one of the few.

    45:13.76

    shefaflow

    Please.

    45:27.92

    Alan Brill

    Real mystical map guidelines of 10 stages emerging into god and in there he talks about alcohol and he basically says alcohol is hearing from afar. It's still external. You haven't mastered the merger because you go up and you come back down or any drug you go up and you come back down so it only goes to what he calls of the 10 stages 5 external five internal. It gets you only up to whether the second or third of the. Ah, external stages but understand that if you really have a map and a training and you know where you're going it plays it does play an incredible role now to the question the mahara of prague a sixteenth century thinker. Actually says what you wanted to say that a the low yada till you don't know the difference is actually reaching a deeper state of consciousness you reach a deeper point than the intellect intellect. You reach a stage of oneness and in the mahara that's getting back to your preface. It's getting back to you in the womb. It's getting back to a place before our persona and masks and therefore on purim is the one day when you reach that secret place that you can do that and therefore you do get as you truly drunk.

    46:58.39

    Alan Brill

    On purim and anybody who is in that tradition of mahaal which would include hasidic groups like abbad who read the mahaal would say similar things I once had a student in an orthodox institution. Who wrote me ah who wrote a paper for one of the ah journals on the mahara and thehaal tradition about how you have really got to reach an altered state on perim and that seems to be the the meaning understand that all the modern orthodox rabbis went ballistic. This is not true. It doesn't say that. Um, even if he did say it. He doesn't mean it. It can't be judaism is about rational. It's against intoxication. It's about this, you know this worldly intellect. You know talmudic legal logic. You know, same logic, you go to law school with um, but it's there. Um, the opposite extreme there was I don't know how much of it's been published. A little bit came out in english there was a habad influencer at the first half of the twentieth century. Caller of Mendel Foot the fuss who actually wrote all of these like um homilies or sermons about the importance of vodka because it's clear. It brings the clear light of the divine. It gives you a sense of god's oneness.

    48:28.40

    Alan Brill

    You're never unless you touched God's oneness through the vodka. Ah you're never going to then be able to go to the more internal stages. So.

    48:42.90

    shefaflow

    So with the encountering of adalo yada regardless of the interpretation I guess I'm also interested then is this something to be integrated for the rest of the year ah is this something that is singularly focused in this point how do and the mahara and others. Um, then begin to talk about that.

    49:06.99

    Alan Brill

    So that becomes your that becomes your tradition meaning you know if for the with a my ra is either once a year or a foot their fasts. It's every for brain and you know every week in you're someplace in between. Um, you know so I can't give a real answer you know at at this point I don't drink anymore from you know, medical reasons that doesn't agree anymore you know, but I teach for example I teach a zohar class once a week locally and 1 of the people who shows is a liver surgeon. And not only does he not drink. He actually encourages the other people there who do bring bottles not to drink because as a liver surgeon you know he's not He's not a particular fan of drinking at this point. So at this point we've got to reach a balance that means something when they get within a given path.

    50:09.37

    shefaflow

    I want to um, make me Zoom out again now that we've kind of hit our our our purim line but I'm interested also then you were talking about states of consciousness as if they. Are true and real. Um I am always interested in the role of doubt and skepticism whether it is with regards to you know the epistemic knowledge of. Ah, psychedelic experience or even our religious and spiritual experiences. Could you talk about? Maybe the the role of doubt or questioning our experiences especially when with regard to psychedelics I think there's a feeling that. This was true and real and I must continue to act. Ah as if um, yeah, please.

    51:05.37

    Alan Brill

    So let's deal with it. First of all, you know is to put it into a context you know whether it's hearing from afar or Selma. You know it all. Both has an effect and at the same time you have to figure out what did it speak to you? Usually you're asking about how to. It's you know what does it mean you here's the questions. What does it mean? What does the message you take from it so in. There's a book called um, responsive from heaven. There was a medieval rabbi who used to ask questions to heaven dream questions.

    51:42.68

    Alan Brill

    And in there you can see. He's not naive and trusting everything he dreams at one point he then asked the same question a second time a third time saying how do I know you're real. How do I know you're not deceiving me how can I trust my experiences. How can I trust my dream. And after he has it 3 times in a row then he trusts it but at the same time if you read it from our perspective. Why is he trusting it because it kept coming back to because I'm in the same answer to it was judge is correct. Other criteria by himself that fits in what I know elsewhere. It wasn't telling him something wild 3 he shared it with those around him and they gave him the certain feedback to yes, this is. After 3 times and you're saying is this a demon. This is a false vision this time it's going to be real. You look at you look at what it is. We have other jewish mystical texts that will be asking. How do I know whether something I experience is it real or demonic. And once again, they would say it's real because I did this this and this and you know this person instructed me and it matches what else I know and then it becomes a certain insult that you give to others your experience is demonic mine is real. Um.

    53:16.90

    Alan Brill

    But there is there is that criteria that it wasn't seen as you can see in the text themselves that record experiences. They're not just saying oh I know that you know I experienced this and therefore I'm going to now I'm Simpleton and I'm going to take it it faces value it really they they then. Question the content they question the means they question you know and then by the end, there's usually these process and it's usually the same in each case they know how they got there then it fits in with what else they know they've shared it with others. It's useful for them.

    53:59.98

    shefaflow

    So would you say then just to just to say it succinctly that um these experiences confer New insight into old information but require some sort of external confirmation.

    54:13.59

    Alan Brill

    Well that goes back to my buddhist and hindu students who laughed at William James saying without a without a without your guru. How do you know? what's real and what's not real. How do you know? what? you should be cultivating what you're focusing on now I'm not saying we have got to adapt. That's that social structure. But.

    54:25.54

    shefaflow

    2

    54:32.60

    Alan Brill

    But there is some sense of you know I mean a lot of us do all sorts of you know, athletic trainings or medical procedures and you touch base whoever's telling you what to do with whether it worked right? or not. You know people have tennis instructors and swimming instructors and golf instructors and your doctor tells you use this machine or take this regiment and you definitely touch base. Um, there has to be some sort of mechanism by which to touch base. Even through you know, call me in three months and let's talk about it or a support or this America small groups working groups in which you pull your knowledge.

    55:22.93

    shefaflow

    Yeah I think one of the one of the people who articulates this best and most consistently is a guy named Joshua Shri from the Emerald Podcast are you familiar? Yeah I think you would love it. But.

    55:36.87

    Alan Brill

    Okay, now.

    55:41.64

    shefaflow

    You know, talking about traditional and indigenous cultures whether they are using psychoactive substances or are specifically focused on the practices which cultivate trance states that. The trans state of the individual is always integrated into ah the myth of the collective and interpreted by the elders and so in that way. Ah. There is an individual experience. But it's always absorbed into the greater whole and this in some way then allows people to I probably achieve some sort of equilibrium right that the new the. Balance between the new insight and the old information with the external confirmation and I think in this atomized and individualized culture especially with psychedelic experience that when there is no myth. To ground 1 ne's direct experience. It might actually be quite dysregulating.

    57:00.90

    Alan Brill

    Okay, so um I hear 3 different questions there. So on 1 hand, the problem that bothered them in the 70 s was the problem with people like Charles Manson who took.

    57:02.98

    shefaflow

    Um, yeah I've got a lot of them.

    57:14.68

    shefaflow

    Um, right.

    57:15.33

    Alan Brill

    Lsd and then commits mass murder. So that's one problem which we're not going to talk about today because that's not what you're asking but understand that they obsessed on that issue once upon a time um 2

    57:25.61

    shefaflow

    Are.

    57:33.93

    Alan Brill

    Is what do you have? the people who are just not part of a path and don't know how to do it. You know you're taking year you're you're thinking of this as the loan to the alone. You don't know what to trust you know how much of this is mixed with your own bad relationship with family and parents and whatever projections and. Regressions you have which is it separate which is problem number 2 and problem number 3 is that we have no collective trans trip tradition for this at this point, the alcohol. Becomes one in which is a collective tradition if you had a mashfia and a hasidic influencer who you know integrated for you. We're now going to have a febraan and you're goingnna drink quite a bit and we're going to talk about god you that the world is an illusion and you're going to come out with a sense that. You know I am I am god and you are god and we're all one and you know that's perfectly fine and fits in a certain role within your spiritual growth that allows you to go back to the text. Um but without any sort of collective image. You know you don't have the same. Um, you know there are many parts of the Zohar that could be a great me and right now I'm going through the introduction which is not a so quote. Unquote cabalistic spirittic text. It's about meeting Elijah on the beach. It's having dreams. It's having visions.

    59:07.12

    Alan Brill

    It's about all sorts of insights. It's about the underworld. It's about the higher garden of Eden in which people experience and come and go and it's a language. Um, you know that that could certainly. The sort of serving text to build something on. But right now there is no current popular tradition outside of very very narrow. Um, you know, usually ultra orthodox small circles.

    59:43.68

    Alan Brill

    Or near or Neo Hasidic small um religious zionist circles. Very little of that.

    59:53.56

    shefaflow

    Well I want to come back to someone that you mentioned when we first began speaking Houston Smith if there's a quote attributed to him and there's I think it's probably. Ah, paraphrase of something he said in cleansing the doors of perception. Um, about the fact that we've been speaking about altered states quite a bit. Um but wanting to understand from your perspective. What does it mean to. Ah, take an altered state and actually translate it into an altered trait.

    01:00:33.36

    Alan Brill

    So I was once on a panel with him back in night right? after graduate school I remember but still been in kind of school my advisor and when we had a panel dealing with these sort of states long time ago and. So Houston had a very clear view of you know there are certain verge virtues. This is supposed to cultivate and that's part of it. A lot of people will get involved in this and you know they did they stay the same it falls away. They begin the same jerks. They always were and clinically. We show. People are just going to go back to being the same jerks if there's no actual tradition that's now going to cultivate our oneness compassion selflessness then. Um, then then if you're going to fall back and Euston Smith believed that that was a certain core of religious life less focused on questions of revelation less quote focused on um, doctrine issues. But the fact that cultivation of the. Those spiritual virtues is what it is really what it's about um and he you know, really liked. You know, spiritual religious communities across the world. He also experienced a lot of them in all different countries in all different ways.

    01:02:03.80

    Alan Brill

    You know he was a wandering I believe methodist as much as I'm a wandering Jew on experiencing this all over the world. Um, you know there are people who you know come down and say that's really what it's about.

    01:02:05.12

    shefaflow

    Is a.

    01:02:20.33

    Alan Brill

    You know doing this. There were many people who used to be involved in the um with the the Siva Foundation who after to both both taking psychedelics and having experienced India coming back that it's about helping the poor and the suddenly doing service and. You know, but you need those organizations not just you're going to give stuck ah to the federation. That's not what this is about. That's not a going to create a certain virtue within you.

    01:06:07.17

    shefaflow

    So I guess this question about altered states to achieving altered traits I think maybe a word for that as well is just healing that psychedelics are being shared. Ah, with regards to individual and collective healing. Do. We also see that in Jewish Mystical and spiritual traditions as well.

    01:06:36.62

    Alan Brill

    Ah, so one all experiences whether mystical or psychedelic or alcohol can go both ways for some people it can mess them up and some people it can be healing and that becomes part of a context and content and all sorts of things. That play a role within it. Um, if the healing certainly now there are several psychologists who are using this for healing. Um, but within it. You now have. The mystical experience is now letting you take on what is called Musara Kabali the cabbalistic ethic of the selflessness of the helping others. You know you meet many who are really quite spiritual quite on the path. Will really help everybody who will put themselves out for others. Um, you know it's not part of our modern making of the modern jew. It's really not but you will certainly see it there once again, you will see various. More pious hasidic groups. The ones you don't usually encounter who really do have a healing e ethos you will see it and certainly within the texts. Um, you know I find things like Coroveros Tomar devaura

    01:08:04.37

    Alan Brill

    Ah, incredibly healing text. But we you know we don't teach it enough. Um that becomes the role now of turning this into a mosar to an ethical path which a lot of people don't really. Want to go that route that going beyond their spirit their materialism and spiritual Materialism. Um, you know that those are all issues that play a role here. But I think it needs to be done. I Think a true a true institution that you may build you know, be somebody who's always bringing this back down. You know someone may teach you give you the path for the experiences but somebody else may always then say let's not bring that that back to The. The compassion, the service meanings of these things If you're looking to staff such an institution and then in terms to hear. We Also see we also use healing in more than one sense.

    01:09:09.57

    shefaflow

    Ah, ah, brick by brick.

    01:09:15.95

    Alan Brill

    Because the difference between now selfless service for others and saying healing. You know your those who believe in the collective trauma of the Jewish people post holocaust and that we have to heal it collectively. That's a different sort of healing.

    01:09:31.83

    shefaflow

    Well maybe we can speak about that another time but Alan Burrell thank you so much for your your wisdom and insight and your brilliance and I'm grateful for your ability to guide this generation of. Jewish psychedelic explorers back to their own traditions.

    01:09:53.22

    Alan Brill

    Well, you're doing all the work I Thank you.

    01:09:57.67

    shefaflow

    All right Hodesh tov.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Dr. Steven Radowitz

In this month’s episode of the Jewish Psychedelic Podcast, Rabbi Zac is joined by Dr. Steven Radowitz, chief medical officer of ⁠Nushama Wellness⁠ in New York. Rabbi Zac and Dr. Radowitz talk about the Jewish mystical tradition and healing, how ketamine therapy is utilized at Nushama, and the role of aesthetics in creating safe and supportive containers for a psychedelic experience.

To stay connected with Nushama, you can follow them on Instagram or visit their website.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

  • Dr. Radowitz has a wealth of experience seeing the effects trauma can have on our physical health firsthand. He joined Nushama to oversee and develop treatment modalities, believing psychedelics are the future of mental wellness as current solutions treat symptoms, not underlying issues.

    Prior, Dr. Radowitz ran the primary care program at Goldman Sachs and practiced internal medicine and primary care since 1998. Originally from Montreal, he completed his M.D. at Chicago Medical School. He worked at St. Vincent’s in general medicine and HIV/AIDS units and was Medical Director of the inpatient alcohol and opiate detox and treatment unit.

    Dr. Radowitz’s focus is preventive medicine, getting to the underlying source before it manifests as “dis-ease,” a misalignment of mind, body, and spirit. He believes psychedelics are a powerful tool to discover the origin of imbalance. On a spiritual journey with Kabbalah, he also studies meditation and yoga. At Nushama, he leads one of the most experienced teams in psychedelic medicine.

  • Zac

    A son of Montreal.

    00:26.18

    Zac

    Okay, where are we holding where are we holding with Leonard Cohen these days.

    00:26.81

    Steven Radowitz

    Well son of Montreal ah was they're going how how how how how is he? How am I being processed through him where individual.

    00:36.91

    Zac

    Yeah, ah if you've been you know smelling the same air and drinking the same water and the same bagels. Maybe there's ah.

    00:42.21

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, yeah, we have I guess I have some element that there's some some of his residue in in me in some way I didn't follow him too much but my biggest memory you know he passed away about a day after after Trump got elected and we were.

    00:58.77

    Zac

    Um, mean that's.

    01:00.36

    Steven Radowitz

    We went to great Barrington We went on this trip with another family and they were this person we went through um, ah leel Leowitz who you might know him mean he's a big writer his family and and he was so distraught by the election and then he was very fond of of him and and.

    01:08.14

    Zac

    Artist Prince Havelet yeah.

    01:20.12

    Steven Radowitz

    The 2 those 2 events together were just a lot for him and it was a very difficult weekend but we pushed through and we ended up having fun. So.

    01:27.79

    Zac

    And what was your jewish upbringing like what what side of Montreal were you raised in.

    01:35.33

    Steven Radowitz

    So yeah, the very you know, sort of a ah verytettle-like environment. Um, we grew up you know because Montreal's was mostly french the jew jewish community lives very very isolated in its own container almost. As do all the other groups. You know the greek people of together the italians the lebanese everyone has their own group. So we really we I lived in a very very a very jewish world I mean I think I didn't I thought the whole world was jewish other than Donny and Marie says he and they have their Christmas specials. I thought the whole world was jewish until I was much older believe it or not you know so I went to jewish school and um and lived a very my grandparents were all born in Europe and lived you know, grew up intetls in Belarus. So or yiddish speaking very warm yiddish-s speaking you know that type of world. And so that was a very big part of my upbringing. So.

    02:28.84

    Zac

    Was was a path of medicine something that was required inspired hinted at or your own inspiration?

    02:40.49

    Steven Radowitz

    Totally my own inspiration and no doctors. My parents are trying. You know they were just trying to survive at that point you know they're immigrants making enough money to get by and so um, yeah, you know. My parents didn't even go to college so it was never a requirement for me. It was my own sort of my own passion sort of I felt like I was sort of just brought there and and I found myself in it rather than it was something that I actively. Made it I mean I had to make a lot of ah large effort to do that. But it it was brought to me. Yeah.

    03:10.90

    Zac

    And was mental health mental health care like your first stop or did you arrive at it at some later point in your training?

    03:16.10

    Steven Radowitz

    Know yeah I mean I know when I when I went into medicine I actually want to be a pediatrician ah and then you know a bunch of very long difficult nights with. Sick children sort of put me off to that and they went into internal medicine but it wasn't one of my passions. My psychiatry residency was very difficult. Um, but it was only by being a primary care doctor and working through you know I really worked through the the aids crisis in the city. Um. I you know I worked I became medical director of an alcohol and heroin Detox Center in this in the in the city in in Manhattan and and then going into primary care I dealt with a lot of mental health tons of it and I started to see actually the link between. Our consciousness our our mind and our mental health and our physical health and that they're not so separate as we think and so I got very much involved and started to really incorporate that into my primary care practice very much. Yeah, so.

    04:19.17

    Zac

    So that meaning just your approach your orientation to your patients or have the interventions that you were suggesting alongside medicine or treatment or therapy.

    04:34.49

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I think yeah I think I have to say really it started I was ah oh god it was about probably about 2015 maybe twenty years ago um I was had a patient of mine. He wasn't even he wasn't jewish. He says you know you should really read this book the power of Kabbalah I'm like this small book and I'm like okay you know and so so so you know I read the book and I don't know it just really it got to me I just it really changed the way I saw the world and I started studying it more and more and getting into it more hasidus. You know and. All that so it wasn't just very esoteric version of of of of Kabbalah by really the hasidic version of it and um and that changed that was my real psychedelic experience actually. And psychedelic and it was like putting on another pair of glasses and seeing the world in just a completely different way so you don't have to do substances to have a psychedelic experience and and I started building on that and building and that completely changed my life in in incredible ways. Um. So and that allowed me also to see medicine in ah in a much more more spiritual way to a point where you know in in physical exams I would always ask people. You know one of my questions was that you know do you have a spiritual life. Is there anything you believe in a higher power. Do you meditate? Do you do yoga like I started asking about other things involving more the spiritual aspect.

    05:59.79

    Steven Radowitz

    Help them also heal from that perspective. So and those who are open to it I Would you know continue and and and guide and those who are not I Would you know sort of redirect and I wouldn't push it on on people. But at least make people aware of it. So.

    06:15.50

    Zac

    So it sounds like you were kind of discovering your own holistic model for your ah approach to ah to patient care. Um, what? what? So the the power of caalah is is a book by Yehuda Berg connected to the kabballa center.

    06:21.91

    Steven Radowitz

    Um, yes.

    06:28.63

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I move. Yeah.

    06:32.83

    Zac

    And that was your first stop in jewish mystical wisdom had you had any encounter in your you know, growing up in a deeply immersive jewish environment jewish school was there any kind of like priming you toward that receptivity I mean kabbalah literally.

    06:35.47

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, yeah.

    06:52.45

    Zac

    Reception receiving. Um, can you maybe imagine any moments in your childhood your adolescent where there was a moment or or several moments of expanded consciousness or was really like the power of Cabalah the.

    06:53.20

    Steven Radowitz

    Mark.

    07:07.31

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, yeah, it woke me up. You know I always had an more of an interest in the religion. But my parents were not religious. You know they're the sort of the post holocaust group they are trying to sort of.

    07:11.25

    Zac

    The the gateway.

    07:18.39

    Steven Radowitz

    Establish themselves. You know in a more modern world after growing up with you know yiddish- speaking grandparents my my father's ah you know my father's family. My father's first language was yiddish you know his parents only spoke yiddish in the home so they were really trying to move away from that so he grew up kosher but then they completely moved away from that. So I really didn't have much of it in the home. But I did always have ah a yearning for it to some extent and then um it was only years and then I really put it to the side for for I wasn't kosher a couple of times you know I I started becoming a little bit more so remember sitting in a restaurant and. In London and I was working there for a summer and I and it hit me I was in a restaurant i's eating pepperoni pizza I'm like just says us and feel right like there's something like I'm a jew you know and I just shouldn't be doing this not that it's bad or good it just it's not what I do and I didn't feel right? So I came home I said mom no more There's no pork and I don't want to eat milk and meat. Was it. We didn't I didn't push the kosher meat yet that would be too much front for at that point I students have but and and I just yeah, so I it definitely was inside of me for sure. But and then yeah, the power of couple it really I think the way I learned judaism in in my jewish school was was. Unfortunately, it was a missed opportunity to to bring people into a more spiritual version. It was not spiritual at all and when I realized what our religion is all about that this the the deep wisdom and it and it's almost like a science. It's it's a way of living your life in such a beautiful way. It's not religion. It's its its essence.

    08:54.65

    Steven Radowitz

    Um, and that really yeah, that that really transformed me so it was really that book and very simple book and then I obviously did other things and I've found my way into other you know, but that was definitely my introduction and a very powerful

    09:08.16

    Zac

    And how did that because I what I I know about you. We had a very long conversation I was hiking somewhere we were on the phone it was during lockdown very memorable conversation talking to a stranger about very deep things.

    09:19.17

    Steven Radowitz

    Um, ah yeah.

    09:26.43

    Zac

    Um, in a moment of planetary crisis. Um, but you know I know that you you've practiced Tm you've done lots of forms of yoga. Um, and so can you talk about that blending of the traditions. What what is that? What is that weave work.

    09:28.30

    Steven Radowitz

    Egypt.

    09:45.00

    Zac

    Look like inside your body inside your heart these days.

    09:47.91

    Steven Radowitz

    I mean you know what's reassuring is when you go and you read all these other things from buddhism to hinduism to yoga to tm. They also sort of say the same thing like there's this. It's it's reassuring to note that there is a universal wisdom out there. There's that there is a structure to this universe and this and spiritual and physical universe. So. And all those things they just they almost say the same thing in different language. Um I like our language It's just the way I was born so you know really, that's why the kabbalah as but but it was it actually helped me get closer to my judaism by sort of venturing into those things and realizing the power and I think. The beauty of of of jewish spiritual wisdom is it takes another level It gives us a purpose an overall purpose. There was something missing in some of those things maybe for me because I am obviously biased. It's my it's it's who I am. It's a huge part of who I am I'm very close I feel very strong about being jewish and very proud to be a jew. Um, but it was beautiful to know so so it brought me all those things brought me closer to brought me closer to um, ah to who I am as a jew yeah, similar of Ramas you know he had the same similarrics. You know. He was. He went really far at the end. It's funny. Yeah I remember I watched and he did go and sort of reconnect to some extent I mean he was never very close to it growing up but he did go back to a rabbi I think and he did find some connection there at the end of his life.

    11:17.81

    Zac

    Yeah, absolutely he you know he cultivated a ah relationship with Reb Zollman um and through Reb Zollman I believe he was introduced to ah like rebi nachman's stories in english and I've I've heard.

    11:22.58

    Steven Radowitz

    Right.

    11:33.20

    Zac

    Ah, recordings of him talking about if that had been available to me before this entire process. Maybe things would be different because this was the first time that I had seen something inside my tradition that spoke to my spirit like that and there's also a great.

    11:51.12

    Steven Radowitz

    Exactly.

    11:56.40

    Zac

    There's a great lecture that he did at the university of judaism it's kind like a black turtleneck and a white jacket and he feels it's he's very tense speaking to this room of jews about ah Judaism and spirituality. Um, but yeah I mean. At some point he recognized there is there is that deep? Well um, but the train for him had kind of passed. Yeah so you're you have this rich inner life sounds like and.

    12:22.43

    Steven Radowitz

    Right? right? Yeah, yeah for.

    12:34.16

    Zac

    You done I think some incredible work in other spheres of of medicine and and patient atuned care tell us how you came to ketamine was was ketamine your first stop? Um I can't imagine that you just landed in a ah. World renowned ketamine clinic where where did where that actually start.

    12:56.40

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, yeah, I mean probably started years ago I have I'm married to a man. Um, yeah, and my my husband at the time after our first son we have 2 children. Um, and our first son was born. He developed really severe headaches. Terrible Headachs I would come on at a specific time and end at a certain time's very odd anyway, anyways went through you know, multiple neurologists and medication he had sinus surgery acupuncture botox everything you name it meditation amittryptylene medications and you know, eventually nothing really fully got rid of them. And then we went. We're actually going with thinking of opening up a more holistic health center and we went to go speak to somebody um about a center that they opened up and the entire conversation was about plant medicine the whole time. So which was interesting and we really hadn't really given it much thought before and but it did you know it was interesting. So. It took us about a year to get there and a year later we said we might as well try it see if it takes away helps with the headaches and in the first journey. Um, we did we went and it was a group journey. Um, we he was shown where the trauma was coming from and completely. Everything completely his headaches completely went away after one. He had a lot of trauma you know, growing up. He was so far he grew up in um, a sephardic very you know sort of orthodox ah community in Paris.

    14:24.23

    Steven Radowitz

    And so religious went to you know orthodox school and all that not alttroers but typical sephardic and um and it was not an easy place to to you know deal with his sexuality of course. Ah, and this really helped him and he ah. And we saw the power in it and then we started experimenting you know excessively. But we we tried a number of different treatments and different types of plants and I saw that this is it's it's just incredibly beautiful work when done you know in ah in a in a in a. In a with intentionality. It's it's incredibly powerful. So the covid hit when covid hit I knew that there's going to be a massive issue with ah mental health and someone called me someone I had met um during one of those experiences and a fellow Canadian and said. You know I'm I'm looking to open up a ketamine center for psychedelic medicine and I need a doctor and um and I said okay and I'll try it I did it part time and I started working it and and after. Working here it it blew me away. It was much more powerful than I had anticipated and much more effective than I had ever anticipated. It would be and soon after about it maybe a year into it I went full time I gave up my private practice and everything and and have it look back.

    15:45.37

    Steven Radowitz

    South.

    15:45.60

    Zac

    Well before we talk about New Shama and um, what what the vision for this clinic is maybe you can talk a little bit about Ketamine Um, So what is Ketamine Often people have. Said Ketamine isn't a psychedelic. So What does that mean? Um, and maybe we can talk about where Ketamine treatment and research is right Now. So Maybe just starting there and.

    16:13.80

    Steven Radowitz

    I mean yeah so ketamine is a really really interesting. Um, medication. It's been It's been around since the 1960 s it was ah it was initially approved as an anis and an aesthetic agent. And an unusually safe anesthetic agent because it's one of the few that has has no effect on people's respiratory drive their heart output so how how their heart beats and their gag reflex. So it's and because of that it's an incredibly safe substance. It's actually on the ah world health organization's um. List of essential medications or drugs to that every country should have proper stores of in case of emergencies. So um, it's used in children and in you know in pediatric cases especially in emergency situations if it got for big breaks of bone or something. It helps really lower. Um, anxiety and pain and it's given in much higher doses actually than what we would use you know even in our centers strangely enough. The interesting thing about ketamine is that you know depending on the dose. It's almost like a different drug There's a completely different effect depending on the on the dose used and the and the root of administration. So you know when um, you know in in high really high doses. It's used as an anaesthetic agent so it can put people out. They lose conscious and it's usually used in conjunction with other anesthetic agents. They usually mix different things to put people to put a people out for surgery in this.

    17:35.78

    Zac

    What would what would be considered a high dose just to give some.

    17:41.40

    Steven Radowitz

    Oh that's really relative to people but you know well over you know, anything like you know over 2 3 three Milligrams per kilogram we dose by weight you know again, some people at two Milligrams they're awake and they can talk to you and other people they're out so it really depends. So. High dose would be well over that you know well over like I'd say definitely over 2 3 um and low doses which can be used. You know you see people doing you know outside with lozenge nasal sprays and done in more recreational settings. Um. It affects different receptors in lower doses and it can be so more euphoric in certain ways or a little bit more of an escape type of of experience but not a psychedelic you know, but when you use it in this sort of middose range so sub-anesthetic under anesthe but more higher than the this sort of recreational general use. Um, it is a psychedelic and anyone who's ever done. It will attest to that. It's probably the most psychedelic substance I've ever experienced my life and I've done I've tried in a number of different substances in controlled settings. Um, ah so yeah, so it's really about how you use it. Um, the safety again is is is unparalled I don't worry about the safety even in very high doses. it's it's it's incredibly safe but in in our clinic we use it in you know a general range of 0.8 to round two milligrams but generally a little bit lower than that. So.

    19:08.37

    Zac

    Just want to pick up on the phrase that you just use. Um, it's the most psychedelic Um, ah most which is funny because when there's like criticism about Ketamine that you hear that it's not a psychedelic. It's a dissociative and so I'm hearing from you very.

    19:13.67

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, the most. So what is like hello.

    19:26.93

    Zac

    Interesting and inverse and intensified understanding. So what does it mean for Ketamine to be the most psychedelic subjectively. What's that subjective experience like yeah.

    19:31.31

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I ah I'll give you like a you know when we use the word dissoci if it's really not. It was a a term used by um, the drug company who Parker Davis who is trying to market it and the sub they they couldn't be the word like. They couldn't use the word psychedelic in those days of course that would be a very bad side effect and no one would use it so they came up with the term dissociative and it's not It's more ego dissociative. So yeah, sort of a dissociation from sense of self the egoic sense of self.

    20:03.99

    Steven Radowitz

    But it doesn't dissociate you from your emotions. There's ah there' a negative connotation to dissociation so in in in severe mental health issues when people have no access they dissociate from their emotions from they they don't have access to their emotions they sort of shut down. That's a different type of of I call that sort of a more of a soul dissociative. But what it does this does it. It inhibits the the processing centers that give you a sense of self so and when you start to take this on. It's almost like a chemical key to the ego and it's it's like ah and ah and and it dims it gradually depending on the dose and as you start to dim it. You take off this filter system. You get to experience reality. In a much more creative and more open way. That's not limited by our fixed sen five senses and so like music when you're listening to and the music has a big influence on what you experience so you'll almost see it's called Synesthesia where you're going to actually see the music. And different tones and different intonations will elicit like um, like ah, many other psychedelic substances will elicit different types of visions and with an eye masks on and earphons noise counseling. It becomes very immersive and you can have incredibly significant sort of dreamlike sequences that seem. Much more real than what we're looking at right now and but if you take off the mask in the earphones and a lot of those visions will go away and if you turn off the drip. It'll you know it dissipates pretty quickly so you know from that perspective. Um, yeah, it's it's it's it's and that's how I think.

    21:33.83

    Steven Radowitz

    But people say so it's really how you use it and the music and and and the environment in the set and we talk about set and setting and that's the same with any substance whether it's any of them the set and setting really does determine your your overall experience and what you're gonna you know, receive from from from this work.

    22:21.18

    Zac

    So you've shared about ah the the set and the setting the importance of music the kind of dosage and the the subjective experience. Um, is there any sort of ah agency in a like it say like a regular dose could a person.

    22:39.17

    Zac

    Take off the mask and start talking at that moment or is there just does that person disappear for a number of hours minutes what actually is happening to that person. Do people still have their agency.

    23:38.57

    Steven Radowitz

    Rights right? Okay yes, they do have their agent during the during the drip and as we escalate the dose obviously it becomes more dissociative see a little bit further away from this version of ourselves. So you know again if we take off the mask and the earphones and we turn off the drip. They'll come back to themselves but you're. You know during the experience you're almost more alert. You're never sleeping. You're more alert and more conscious than you are right now and you know what comes up in these journeys also to turn from the from the actual music is a big part of it is. You're sort of this beautiful like kind. There's this consciousness watching it happen I call it liquid meditation. So it allows us the the the the visuals that you see come and then the music stops and everything sort of dissolves and you may dissolve with it that is a backdrop to you appreciating who we are this beautiful calm presence just watching it come and go and and and the. The the these unbelievable multidimensional experiences are just there for you to appreciate that and I think it's like it's like that in life I think we're here to appreciate the godliness inside of us through. Some of the darkness. It's like ah you know I give the example like you know how you kind of appreciate a candle you take a candle and you put it up to the Sun. You don't appreciate it. But you take a candle and you put it into a dark room. You can start to appreciate the beauty of the flame and the area the blue area around the wick you appreciate it. So I think some of the of what we experience in this physical world is just there.

    25:03.35

    Steven Radowitz

    As a backdrop as ah as a contrast to appreciate the beauty you know within us and I think that's the power of this type of medicine and and this type of work. Yeah.

    25:12.61

    Zac

    And with with other types of psychoactive substances can people also have difficult painful bad um, frightening experiences with Ketamine or do you see? ah. Fewer of those with this particular substance where does it fall.

    25:30.19

    Steven Radowitz

    No I think so it depends on what people are coming into the journey with we do encourage people to do some work before so you know intention we prepare people they we send them intentions worksheets they work with the integration coach before to prepare them I talk to them so we prepare them but I don't believe in bad trips. It's only bad if it's not contained and not processed properly then you can a difficult journey can turn bad. It's like in life. You know we can either learn from our difficult experiences or can become turned into trauma and and entrenched in our in our psyche if we but we can see but every one of every experience in life. there's a jewel I believe there's there's some wisdom. Some strength to be gained gained from that and the same thing in these journeys it's just um, if if it's properly processed I found that the difficult experiences during a psychedelic you know journey could be the most ah therapeutic and most helpful and that's what I see here. I don't believe that anyone goes anywhere. They're not meant to go and I really believe this and I believe this gets a little spiritual I guess this is a proper place to discuss this because some people wise but I believe it's your soul. It's your essence guiding the entire thing and you don't go anywhere. You're not meant to go and I've done I've seen I don't know close to 9000 of these.

    26:34.41

    Zac

    Um, yeah, talk about it.

    26:45.40

    Steven Radowitz

    Come through here and even the most difficult ones and I've seen some difficult ones have been the most healing you know, but again, it's how it's like in ino in kabbal or in in jewish missism like the way interpreting a dream and every night we go to sleep. It's a psychedelic experience. It's crazy if you think about sleep. You know we have to let go. It's almost like I mean we consider it almost a mini death and within those experiences doing it. You can have a bad There's no such thing as a really bad dream as this can be a bad interpretation and we're told to be very careful who we ask to interpret who we tell our dreams to. Very you have to be very careful with that and the same thing I think with a psychedelic experience. You have to have the proper person to interpret what comes up in these other states.

    27:27.63

    Zac

    Yeah, and even the the ritual even the liturgy is that a nightmare can be interpreted Litova could but it could be interpreted for the good as a bracha and not necessarily as as a curse or some demonic presence or.

    27:47.35

    Zac

    Vision. So it's interesting perspective maybe get into you know the nature of challenging experiences another time. But so we've been talking about Ketamine set setting music but I want to talk about where it's all happening for you I Want to talk about New Shama. Um, where did you did.

    28:02.49

    Steven Radowitz

    Um, yeah nation.

    28:04.92

    Zac

    Did you help found new shama did you came in at the same time while it was being founded and what does new Shama mean.

    28:07.61

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah, so new shama um, Rich Melo came up with the name. Um, so it comes from its obviously comes from the name neshamma and they're singing 5 levels of the soul and in in jewish mysticism and the one in the middle is neshamma. It's the balance. It's the between the more ethereal parts of our soul. It's like almost like ah ah a a cord a umbilical cord up to to the upper worlds to to god and so oh god's everywhere along every level but that's ah, but and and there's and then there's more manifests. There's sort of lower levels of it. And the schum is about you know, finding that middle ground between so it's all about I see it's all about balancing so I got in. That's where the name comes from also new shaman. So new shaman. So that's sort of a plan where both of those words. Um.

    28:55.91

    Zac

    Hey, ah.

    28:59.33

    Steven Radowitz

    We're all were 3 jews both all of us are canadian jews who came up with it. So I thought it was appropriate Kate well started the center and so yeah, so I was in at the beginning of this and helped sort of guide it and take a more maybe um, a little bit more of a spiritual approach to this sort of I see it as a as a um. As a ah midway between medicine you know, science and spirituality and I don't think I don't see spirituality as non-science I think it is a science that we're just not there. We're not that advanced as advanced as we think we are. We're not. You know youre Kabul. it's it's science it's just when they get there. But.

    29:36.70

    Zac

    Well something that struck me about the the space itself so you're located in Midtown New York um you are in a beautiful building. You take an elevator all the way up and when you exit the elevator what I was.

    29:44.89

    Steven Radowitz

    Yes, yet.

    29:51.88

    Zac

    Really struck by and the only thing that came to my mind is this is a psychedelic space. Um there you know the the detail to beauty and ease softness ah natural tones. A lot of green a lot of brown. Um, soft pink and orange. There are books. There's Safari you you have some of the the greats of psychedelic literature and what really struck me which was a ah surprise is when you're walking through the hall of ah the treatment rooms. All of the rooms are named after particular people can you tell us about the decision and what's the what's the aesthetic that you're going for other than psychedelic like why this kind of space.

    30:40.94

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I mean we try to sort of declinicalize as much as possible I think it's important. Um, you know it's a place where we're opening ourselves up our souls up so you know and when you do that I think having a nurturing environment is very important people have to feel safe when you go into a psychedelic experience if you feel safe and held. And we have reverence to the people actually who brought this beautiful work to us. Um, so there's a respect for that too. Um I think you're more likely to have a better and a more meaningful experience so we did a love. We spent a lot of time and effort and money to to create this. You know a play set that. Um. That really that leads to to that place of safety and openness so that was a big part even them reading the books and everything and then the staff in the way we train. Our staff is very important. You know everybody here you know goes through the treatment. We would never give anyone a treatment that we ourselves wouldn't take or we wouldn't give to our loved ones we have you know? So um, so people hopefully when they come in here. They feel like they're going. They're not walking into just another medical clinic. They're at least not now. Maybe a medical clinic. Hopefully what will what they'll look like in in in maybe 100 years from now majority. Yeah.

    31:58.17

    Zac

    It's It's deeply beautiful and clearly reverential, especially for some of the luminaries of the psychedelic field. You know the the the placard of the griffiths room when I was there. Especially.

    32:05.81

    Steven Radowitz

    Them right. With you.

    32:15.17

    Zac

    After he had Roland Griffiths who is the lead researcher at Johns Hopkins had just passed away. So um, so you have this beautiful space. You're doing this beautiful work and I'm interested I think.

    32:18.40

    Steven Radowitz

    Right? Teach us class. You know.

    32:31.52

    Zac

    Probably most people who encounter ketamine certainly on social media are encountering ads most likely on Facebook Instagram for at home ketamine so yours is decidedly not at home. Um, you've created a date a home away from home spiritual home away from home but can you talk a little bit about the difference between what you are doing and what some of these at-home ketamine treatments are offering.

    33:01.45

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I think what we're offering here is true psychedelic I so I'm very strict psychedelic medicine and psychedelic medicine is is is like like I talked about when I my had my so my my psychedelic experience with with spirituality. Um, with with studying Kabbalah it's same thing with this substance I think it's about opening ourselves up to seeing the world in a new way. It's not about it's about expression. It's about expressing our emotion expressing ourselves expressing our souls not suppressing and. Any agent. You know there's a lot of agents that there to to just suppress the emotions and I don't think that's the point here. So I think you know take home ketamine it makes you feel good. You know you'll take it. You'll feel good and you'll take people tend to take it when you know feeling a little stressed or anxious or but overall I think that. I think it's more It's its intent is more suppression if you know most of the most of these outfits they tend to you know it's it's an ongoing treatment and I've had a number of people come into our center who are taking it who have taken it and didn't really find much help with it. They found that they were given a lot of um. These sort of lozenges or a nasal spray and with no direction. No integration at all and they're doing it alone sharing it with their friends and I think it's quite dangerous personally not not only physically dangerous. You know as we've seen recently. Um you know with Matthew Perry but

    34:23.75

    Steven Radowitz

    I Think it's also irresponsible from a spiritual perspective to go into these states and not have any so have anyone guide to you and if someone does have a bad experience or a difficult experience like there's no one there to reframe that to help people especially people with significant mental health issues. So to me, it's just like we already have enough agents out there to.

    34:30:10

    Zac

    Um, yeah.

    34:42.69

    Steven Radowitz

    To knock us out. You know we could take benzodiazepines which are overused and we have you know opiates and we have ah you know Marijuana or other Drugs. You know that we can use to escape you know if if it used in Excess. So um. I Just don't want to see Ketamine used as that I don't think that's the poor purpose of of of Ketamine. Yeah.

    35:03.17

    Zac

    And not only the the purpose of ketamine but I've always been ah confused that the the set and the setting that you have described and and cultivated. It's. In someone's home. They're on their couch. They're alone and the idea of um, the safety that you are striving to provide the the relational quality of the way that I'm hearing you with your staff and with your clients with yourself your family. Um. So it feels like it's at odds with what you're saying is a a psychedelic experience or not a psychedelic experience but 1 of of isolation.

    35:47.10

    Steven Radowitz

    A bi. So yeah I think that's the problem so people wake up and they're alone. You know people have a lot of and that's one of the triggers for many people um, feeling like you get this high and then you just drop out of it and then you're sitting in your room by yourself alone like and and then just need more and more and then it's. Just encourages people to use more and more of this and I think it's it's dangerous hear what we do, you know everybody who comes through our our center has to go through a so you know a medical and psychiatric um screening evaluation with me or and we have nurse practitioners and it's about an hour long intake. Go into the details of their history and make sure it's you know a proper option good option and a safe option for them. A lot of these at home thing they do I think about a 15 minute some type of like you know, just a very cursory exam that's done online and they're never seen by a provider again. So um, when they come in here you know they have nursing assessment. They check their vitals and blood pressure. They you know an iv is place. We have um, ma's nurses and we have integration coaches who work with them before and after they have the medical staff myself and m you know who's really there to make sure that they're there in a safe environment. They feel safe and when you feel safe and you're contain. You're much more likely to have a good response. You're more likely to expose and and and reveal what you need to has to be revealed in in during these type of treatments. So.

    37:19.98

    Zac

    Yeah I guess we you know we were just focusing on at home Ketamine Therapy Um, and some of the the cons the discontents of that model I think I've the people that I have spoken to most trying to do some Jewish integration work specifically with ketamine.

    37:27.37

    Zac

    Um, has not been at home. But in particular Ketamine clinics where they're strapped to ah ah, an exam table. There's nothing on the wall. There's not even any music at all but given a shot or an Iv and then are checked in on maybe in.

    37:39.28

    Steven Radowitz

    Language.

    37:47.17

    Zac

    In 45 minutes to an hour

    37:49.52

    Steven Radowitz

    yeah yeah I mean I couldn't imagine doing that having done it myself I think a lot of these clinics I bet you if you ask the doctors have never put themselves through a ketamine infusion I know what for a fact that many of them haven't um I think it's important. Um, because. And after I did mine and how and I know the depth of it and it was one of the most um one of the most significant experiences I've ever had including you know ayahuasca and mushrooms and ah and san pedro and everything else I've done um, it was by far the most most the deepest experience I've ever had. And I had a lot of reverence and a lot of respect for this medicine. So um, so when I'm I'm in there I when I'm giving it I give it with a lot of care and a lot of reverence and and and humility. Um, because it humbled me. You know when I did my last one at the end I remember saying. God I know like this is the god I was really left with like god I know nothing I know nothing I know like I surrendered to just knowing nothing and it was so powerful and was beautiful and it's like 1 of the you know I try and it's one of my my mantras before I walk into a room I try and say god I know nothing I know nothing I know nothing let me just be a channel you know and it's. To go in there with that humility that this helps you get to was very powerful and that's why I thought it was very important that I do that so to be. You know, put onto ah a a a stretcher in a room and put through one of these experiences you can do it? Maybe it'll help some people you know it's possible. But.

    39:18.25

    Steven Radowitz

    You know it's just going to be very different and I don't think it's I don't think it's the way to do. It's not psychedelic medicine and a lot of people see this as just another chemical. You know, agent to a drug. That's just going to cure. People's depression. But I don't see depression or anxiety as a disease that needs to be cured. That's another controversial There could be a whole other podcast. Not to say that it's not real I'm just saying I don't think it's a genetic and they've actually you know this they've done you know, ah, the national institute of of mental health um has spent billions. Billions of dollars trying to try try to find a ah gene for depression for mood disorders trying to find some type of chemical or a biomarker for mood disorders and they found nothing There's books about this and so I think I see you know depression or um, our emotions in general are just like sort of messengers of. Letting us know that there's some type of psychospiritual misalignment in our life and they're just there like if pain god forbid someone breaks a leg is the pain a disease. No the pain's a messenger letting you know there's a bone out of alignment I could load people up with pain medications and morphine and they can walk on the broken leg. But they're not going to go eventually, you're going to need more and more the morphine and you're going to have to take care of it at some point or we can put on a cast let the bone heal and eventually that becomes the the pain is no longer necessary the same thing with with mood disorders I think a lot of it is just entrenched and we don't listen to ourselves. We don't listen to the messages. Um.

    40:47.86

    Steven Radowitz

    It to you know it will get entrenched and and become more of a disorder. So.

    40:52.42

    Zac

    What's the line I'm going to butcher every aspect of the next string of words I think it might is it from Krishna Murti the idea that what you're describing is a a reasonable response to an unreasonable situation or. Something like that I had to go back? Um, but of of course people are suffering from these kinds of maladies given ah the state of the world that we live in and it's not the hope would not be to suppress that there is nothing to heal because it's not.

    41:09.72

    Steven Radowitz

    Um, you did? Yeah yeah.

    41:28.66

    Zac

    Ah them that needs to heal. But the conditions outside of them which are in need of healing themselves. Yeah yeah.

    41:33.17

    Steven Radowitz

    Or our relation to them too and how we see them. You know, look at them as opportunities not react to them in a negative way but find more love through them and then we connect as agents of love and enough people think that way. That's we'll get rid of that's how we'll get rid of. All the Wars and all the you know so we can only do what we can do. But at least if we can change people's perspective and what's in front of them and make them a little less reactive and a little bit more thoughtful in how they see you know their family and see the people that trigger them. Um I think that will bring yeah most likely to bring peace and.

    41:53.29

    Zac

    Plants.

    42:08.69

    Steven Radowitz

    Themselves and to then the people around them. So yeah.

    42:10.17

    Zac

    Well you mentioned a couple minutes ago about Matthew Perry just in passing so as of December Twenty First twenty twenty three I believe it's about a week ago that the actor Matthew Perry from friends among other things who.

    42:21.48

    Steven Radowitz

    Here.

    42:28.69

    Zac

    Famously Very publicly has struggled with addiction and abuse of various substances. Um the the media report is that he drowned in his hot tub because of a Ketamine overdose.

    42:44.92

    Steven Radowitz

    Life.

    42:47.85

    Zac

    And so I think that there has been after that some question concern a lot of activity online and social media about yay or nay ketamine including I think I saw something from New Shama specifically about this and from you specifically? Um, so. How does ah a ketamine clinic with a deep belief in using this medicine in a good way. The way that you have described um to this situation which is very public and now is there. The substance itself is drawing a more criticism than before.

    43:23.90

    Steven Radowitz

    You know, First of all, it shouldn't be given at home to someone who has an addiction you know well-known history of addiction. He was on buprenorphine for opiate abuse he had benzodiazepines in his system larazeem and smaller doses of chonazepam. So he's on 2 different benzodiazepines which are also suppressive. Um, you know and and together with the the the buprenorphine and the ketamine not a good mix. You know if he was observed if he was there with someone he would have never died. He didn't die of ketamine poisoning or overdose he died from drowning. Under the influence and you shouldn't be doing any type of age and I don't care if it's alcohol ketamine benzodiazepines in a hot tub by yourself period you know? So I think it's it's you know I don't think I think there's many things that went wrong here but he did not die of ketamine. overdose I mean you have to to die of a ketamine overdose I mean you have to take enormous amounts even higher they say it was aesthetic doses even the doses he had in his system wouldn't directly kill him. It would not suppress his respiratory rate. It would not so decrease his his cardiac output or his gag reflex. He didn't die of that you just you know he was in a. Very deep state to probably due to the mixing of the drugs and he fell asleep and or he he passed out in a hot tub which is understandable the same way. Whitney Houston died in a hot tub from I think Ben's I don't know what she was taking but um, it's unfortunate and it's it's very sad. Um.

    44:52.39

    Steven Radowitz

    You know and and how he got this home tech this Ketamine at home I have no idea but no one should have prescribed him home Ketamine knowing his his diction history. So I think this would never have happened obviously in a medical setting. So.

    45:06.56

    Zac

    But ah connecting it to his own history of of addiction. Can you talk about or share your perspective with regards to ketamine which is often characterized as being different from classic psychedelics. Mushroom or cacti or ayahuasca as actually being addictive that one can get addicted to ketamine and that sets it apart and in some ways a negative way. We saw it in California when the bill was going through the state legislature and ketamine was one of the substances that was.

    45:45.34

    Zac

    Slated to be decriminalized to that Ketamine was actually removed because of or at least they say Ketamine was removed for that reason. So as a Ketamine Clinician Can you speak to that and what should people really know.

    45:59.88

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah I agree with that that I don't think it should be decriminalized or or you know allowed to without a prescription I think it it in low doses like I said you know Ketamine The the effects of Ketamine are very dependent on the on the dose the root of administration. And and you know and and yeah and and and how long you use you. It's infused through so in lower doses. It can have a euphoric ah sort of a and ah so a non-psychedelic euphoric effect and it can be addictive and it's been shown to be addictive and it shouldn't be used. That's the dangers of all these home Ketamine centers people can just take a little bit of ah, a little spritz here and there every time they're feeling stressed out and you get high and you start seeing people using it all the time and that's Dangerous. It has many dangerous regular use of Ketamine on a daily basis can affect the bladder. It. It can affect a lot of things people adapt to it. There's dangers and it should not be used on a daily basis. So I don't think it should be sort of quote unquote not criminalized, but it shouldn't be used without a prescription for sure and I don't even think it should be used at home. You know on a regular without without proper um integration and and care and you know. And maybe in ah in a therapist's office. Observed you know and and when the doses is is properly given Yes, but not, you know, just to hand people a month supply of Ketamine to use ah as they as they so fit. So um, yeah I don't.

    47:31.50

    Steven Radowitz

    I Do think that we have to be careful with this substance as any substance. That's mind altering and should be used with reverence and with respect and like any of them. But yeah, so hope that answer your question.

    47:45.50

    Zac

    Ah, we're so we're getting to the end of our time together and I was wondering as a lover of Jewish Mystical Wisdom and the kabbalistic and hasidic tradition is there a particular teaching that is. On your heart mind spirit from any particular book or Thinker a writer that is influencing or guiding your work at the present moment.

    48:04.65

    Steven Radowitz

    I mean I love you know I always listening this I love Rob Nachman's you know work of course. Um one one sentence that really stuck out to me one sort of bit of of spiritual wisdom that i. I repeat to many of my members here and myself often is is ah this idea of like mati alo mai I love that is to go for something to desire something to want something to want to receive something but also at the same time to let go of it and and to be in this non-dualistic state with our desires and to always.

    48:48.34

    Steven Radowitz

    So like to say okay you know I want that beautiful house but you know and if it doesn't get things don't work out god doesn't it's not for me that there's something better for me might be something maybe even a smaller house. But maybe I'll be happy in that small house. There's so there's a path for me that god wish and to be more open. And and free to have so it doesn't mean we don't have desire. This is the beauty of judaism and Kabala is to acknowledge those 2 parts to us and to live in in harmony and balance with those 2 parts but to you know and and so and I found that very helpful my life so I have desires I want but at the same time as I wanting them let go of them doesn't mean but I'm still going for them. But I'm letting go of them and I found when I started really like really trying to live through that it changed my life. It's just it's it's ah it's a beautiful way to live so that's something that really stuck out for me out of all the years of my and and love and all these other things of course, but that. That's a very practical tool. Yeah, oh.

    49:44.24

    Zac

    Well inspired by that Aramaic phrase that you shared mati vlomati touching and not touching we've we've touched on so many important topics and lo mati. There's so much more to discover and discuss so we'll leave it here today. Dr Steven radowitz

    49:49.42

    Steven Radowitz

    Yeah. Thank you Rabbi Zach thank you very much for having me I appreciate him? Okay, right? It was okay.

    50:04.23

    Zac

    Thank you for being with us.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Tamara Pearl

Content Warning: This conversation will touch on topics of kidnapping, terrorism and violence including murder.

In 2002, Tamara Pearl learned that her brother, Daniel, had been abducted and murdered by Al-Qaeda in Pakistan. For over twenty years, she has worked with this personal “waking nightmare” as an inquiry into the nature of evil and how individuals and communities create containers of healing to move from fragmentation to wholeness. In this conversation, Rabbi Zac will speak to Tamara about her own healing journey, as a Jewish psychedelic-assisted therapist living in a time of tragedy and confusion, what tools, skills and inner resources we can rely on when we encounter pain, betrayal, and evil in and out of psychedelic consciousness.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Madison Margolin

.On this episode of the Jewish Psychedelic Podcast, Rabbi Zac speaks with riter, journalist, editor, consultant, educator, and guide to all things Jewish-Psychedelic. Madison speaks about her family and growing up with Ram Dass, her psychedelic journey to Jewish spiritual practice, and what she things are the most important happenings in Jewish psychedelic space. These stories and more can be found in her forthcoming memoir, Exile and Ecstacy, now available for pre-order. Stay connected with Madison on Instagram ⁠⁠@madisonmargolin and at her website.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Rabbi Yosef Goldman

On this episode of the Jewish Psychedelic Podcast, Rabbi Zac is joined by Rabbi Yosef Goldman, composer, prayer leader, educator, and singer. Yosef’s new album of Jewish music, “Abitah,” will be released on Rising Song Records on September 21st. The conversation delves into the profound connections between music and Torah, creativity as a Jewish practice for healing, and spiritual connection, celebrating the spirit of this sacred month of Elul.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & The Harvard Divinity Panel

Throughout millennia, Jews have explored individual and communal consciousness through a variety of techniques and traditions. More recently, Jews have played an outsized role in the “psychedelic renaissance” as researchers, practitioners, and advocates, including prominent leaders. A surge of interest in these substances creates an opportunity to reflect on non-ordinary experiences in Jewish life and theology more broadly.

This podcast is offered as a free community resource by Shefa: Jewish Psychedelic Support. If you feel moved to donate to support this work, ⁠you may do so on our ⁠⁠⁠website here.⁠⁠⁠

Our intro and outro music is an excerpt of the song ⁠Ein Od⁠ by ⁠Yosef Goldman⁠.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Rabbi Aaron Cherniak

.Psychedelic science, focused mostly on the medicalization of certain psychoactive substances, has also inspired new perspectives on the science of spirituality and consciousness. What aspects of psychedelic experience are worthwhile to examine from a scientific and/or spiritual perspective? How if at all can spiritual experiences and their effects be measured? What outcomes should be linked to experiences labeled spiritual? Which outcomes should we aim for and how can spiritual experiences be optimized for greater health and well-being?

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Lauren Taus

At a time of great diversity of backgrounds, commitments, and identities, many of Jews are still carrying the wounds of religious and cultural traumas of being “not enough” or “too much” in some significant way. How can deep self-love and acceptance heal and transform our relationships with lineages and traditions which once brought us pain? How can walking the path of a Jewish mystic deepen our appreciation for psychedelic work? These programs are offered as a free community resource.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Dr. Ido Cohen

What is a “psychedelic experience” or an “expanded state of consciousness”? How do we understand these phenomena, both psychologically and spiritually? How can Jewish people begin to integrate the concepts and practices of “transpersonal psychology” into their own healing work and spiritual development? In this community conversation, we are joined by Dr. Ido Cohen, Psy.D, to learn about the history of this area of psychology, his journey back to Jewish wisdom and practice, and the power of visualization to transform spiritual practice.

R’ Zac Kamenetz & Bob Otis

What does it mean to regard plants as sacred, or even as a “sacrament,”, and to create community with entheogenic plants as a necessary means for helping facilitate connection to sacred Divine presence? We welcome Bob “Otis” Stanley, Senior Pastor of the Sacred Garden Community Church, to speak about his path toward sacred plant use and his vision for helping root entheogenic spiritual communities. Bob has over 40 years of engagement with family, traditional and Western teachers guide Bob’s work with natural Sacraments, supported by degrees in psychology, sociology and Divinity (MA, University Chicago). Bob was founding Chairperson for Decriminalize Nature Oakland, is senior Pastor for Sacred Garden Community Church, co-founder of Sacred Plant Alliance, and Board Chair for Alma Institute.